Jason Hensley
Dr. Webb
Writing 010
1 February 2017
The Mexican Border Wall: Expensive and Dangerous On January 20th, 2017, history was made in the United
States of America. The 45th president of the U.S., Donald Trump, was officially sworn in to office. Not a full week later, Trump is issuing an executive order to construct a controversial
Mexican Border Wall that he vehemently emphasized during his campaign. The Constitution cordially states that people have the right "[T]o petition the Government for a redress of grievances." (US Const. amend. I). While the wall may not be illegal: the impractical cost, threat of racism, and possible excuse for war make the wall not only impractical but dangerous for all American citizens.
…show more content…
During his entire campaign, Trump promised Mexico would be paying for the wall.
Hensley 2
Now, Mexico is saying that they will not pay a single penny for the wall. This proves to be a problem for American citizens as it will increase taxes because building such a large wall is expensive. In essence, this wall is just an impractical cost for the United States. Yes, Mexican immigration is a problem but building a wall is a very immature and expensive way of dealing with it. The proper definition racism states, "discrimination or prejudice against people of a different race in belief that one's race is superior to another". With the wall and Trump proclaiming "all Mexicans all criminals" racism is clearly at an all-time high against Mexicans. We have even come as far as to give "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude."
(US Const. amend. XV). It is obvious America has come a long way since discrimination was prominent but, with Trump in office that may soon
…show more content…
They were grape pickers, in other words, they did the job that rich people, like Trump, did not want to do. Do I agree there is a problem with illegal immigrants? Yes, but building a wall to complete racist ideals is not the appropriate solution to an immigration problem. The Preamble to the Constitution states that the people are supposed to help "…insure domestic tranquility…". I have always taken this as the people having to help protect each other on their home turf. Trump is not providing this "domestic tranquility" for us as of right now because of his wall. Each day, I wonder when Mexico is finally going to decide they have had enough and potentially go to war with us. We will be feuding with our very own neighbor. Jorge Castañeda, a former foreign minister of Mexico, said via Washington Post that Mexico "will have for the next four years, at least, a president of the
United States who actively campaigned and centrally campaigned against Mexico’s interests." Even Mexico officials are getting annoyed by Trump but, what will it lead to? Will it eventually lead to enough tensions to cause war? Mexico will have
Thomas Paine spoke of America as a place of diverse cultures, a “mixing pot”. But, as time has continued, Paine’s idea of a country of different speaking people living in unison, has changed greatly. The climax of this universal prejudice towards immigrants began for many Americans on September 11, 1999. Since the tragic terrorist attack on the World Trade Centers, citizens began to question the immigrant security of America. Fast forwarding ten years after many more terrorist attacks, Donald Trump along with many Americans support the idea of building a wall to block out immigrants from the southern border. Some supporters believe the wall would protect the people, protect the goverment, and protect the country as a whole. However, other
All through America's history it always had a presidential election every four years, and last years presidential election campaign there were two leading candidates, so to ensure their victory, they both made promises significant changes, creation. All through last year's campaign, a candidate named Donald J. Trump made several promises, and one of his promises could change the way of life in American. Mr.Trump won last years presidential election, and all eyes were on him to the promise vowed to do if and when he is president. That one promise which is opposed by six in ten Americans is that President Trump promised a 'big, beautiful wall' that would be placed on the Mexican and American border. President Trump Proposed that he could construct the wall for 8 billion, but now it is known that wall will cost about $21.6 billion for the wall and that the $21.6 plan doesn't include the $150 million a year to maintain. America shouldn’t Build a Wall along the US/Mexico Border because of the high cost and how it will affect America's economy, also thought the wall would keep out undocumented immigrant from crossing the US border but it is shown that undocumented immigrants contribute over $11 billion to the US economy each year, and lastly the environment that is near the border, and how it will be affected and disturbed due to the construction the border wall.
The 45th president of the United States of America, Donald J. Trump, is a political man who has many ideas to improve the U.S. One of the many idea he had included building a wall between the borders of the United States and Mexico for the “purpose of controlling immigration into America”. According to Trump this wall is supposed to help our country with its national security. In reality though, many people believe that the wall is showing Trumps true colors. Many people are contemplating on the fact if Trump is a racist person who is building the wall because it provides a method of targeting and preventing those who are trying to cross the Mexican-American Border. In reality, Trump only cares about trying to make “America Great Again”, and
The border wall is an uncertain investment to many considering the price tag it holds, but if it is to limit illegal immigration and over time stop the trickle of illegals coming into America the payout would be well worth it. Anyone has the right to disagree with the current president and his policies, but it is rather difficult to deny to growing statistics that prove how illegal immigration is negatively affecting the U.S. America is in deep trouble right now with the great political divide that separates this country and everyone needs to come together and focus on one common goal which is persevering the greatness of the
Donald Trump wants to build a wall. Donald Trump wants to build a wall for a few, invalid reasons, and yet he is the frontrunner in the race for Republican presidential nominee. Everyday, more people begin to support the idea of building a border between the United States and Mexico. Supporters offer a few reasons - safety, the economy, legality - but few supporters look deeper than Trump’s explanations. Supporters of a wall are surprisingly ignorant about their own causes, as well as the opposition to their cause. Becoming educated about the topic of a border wall would show the supporters that a border wall would actually be ineffective and unnecessary because the wall would fail to stop over half the illegal immigrants that enter the United States, the concept of a border wall is against what the United States stands for, and the border wall would be a costly venture that
In 2014, the budget for the United States border patrol was upwards of $3.5 billion according to the CBP. This country is already spending an absurd amount of money on border control. Despite all of this funding undocumented immigration still runs rampant. Let's face that facts Donald, increased border protection doesn't work. As Malcolm Galdwell would say, it follows the inverted-u logic. Put simply Border Patrol produces diminishing returns and may even increase undocumented immigration. All the "Mexican Great Wall" does is just further prove Trump's animosity towards hispanics.
Mexican citizens won't be able to cross the border with the wall up, right? Sure, it is true that people won't be able to run across the border, but not even half of the illegal immigrants in the US get in that way. Most illegal Mexican immigrants get into the US legally, and overstay their VISAs. Not only will the wall fail to keep illegal immigrants out, it will only make the situation worse. Building the wall will monopolize border crossing for the cartel. Any good businessman knows that as soon as something is illegal or prohibited, the price goes up for underground businesses. The Mexican Cartel will be able to make more profit and therefore grow if we build this
Immigration has been a controversial subject over the years, especially when the time comes for Presidential elections, but while legislators play politics, the immigration problem has continued to be unresolved. The future will tell whether the immigration reform will resolve the problem of millions of immigrants who already reside in the United States, or the problem will continue to be ignored until another presidential term. Very little has been done in the past or is being done in the present to resolve any of the issues surrounding immigration.
“In 2014, 5.8 million unauthorized immigrants from Mexico lived in the U.S.,” according to Pew Research Center (Krogstad). Regulating the number of illegal immigrants from entering the United States has become an increasingly significant issue for the federal government’s agenda after, the number of unauthorized immigrants reached a peak in 2007 at 12.2 million, when this group made up 4% of the U.S. population (Krogstad). An abundance of proposed solutions have been offered to limit the steadily increasing number of illegal immigrants from reaching American soil, such as: mandating E-verify, a system that determines whether or a not a person is eligible to work in the United states, strengthening border security, and fortifying interior enforcement measures in the United States (Illegal Immigration and Border Security). Another major plan sources from President Donald Trump, who hopes to build a wall spanning between the United States and Mexico. This idea has ignited numerous opposing arguments that have picked out its irrationalities, and display how Donald Trump’s proposal to erect a wall generates more complications than benefits.
There exists a problem in America today that cannot fail to enter the houses of every citizen, influence the thoughts of every individual, and stir the wild imaginations of every free thinker: the problem of illegal aliens traversing the sacred borders of our beloved country. Certain individuals have recently proposed ideas regarding this that have entranced the American people, advocating building a wall separating the United States from its long-time neighbor and trade-partner Mexico. However, after much consideration and calculation I have found his idea grossly mistaken in its computation. A simple wall will be insufficient and far too conservative to solve this crisis of borders. Therefore, in response to America's growing interest in
This people worry about losing jobs and opportunities and also the safety of this country from while allowing new citizens into this country. Many believe that this type of behavior against people will shine a negative light on America as a whole. Omar Jadwat, director of the American Civil Liberties Union's Immigrants' Rights Project, said the president Trump intention to build a border wall was "driven by racial and ethnic bias that disgraces America's proud tradition of protecting vulnerable migrants." (Chicago Tribune). This information by itself makes America seem opposing to diversity. America is the “land of the free” but these immigration policies would show that America, or at least the president, has no tolerance or acceptance of people of different backgrounds than what is considered “normal”. President Trump’s plan to build a wall is extremely nonsensical on how he plans to get it done. It makes sense to build a border wall against individuals against America, but why just build a wall on the south border of America? The north is just as dangerous with smugglers entering America as drug and human traffickers. Ron Nixon, of The New York Times wrote, “Since the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the Department of Homeland Security has increased the number of Border Patrol agents stationed along the Northern border to more than 2,000, from about 340, in addition to adding ground sensors,
Those living in border states such as Arizona, California, New Mexico, and Texas are most affected by Mexico’s proximity and the controversy with immigration. As someone who lives in one of the southernmost cities in California, I can attest to the large population of Mexican people, who are here with legalized papers whether it be citizenship or residency - in my almost 20 years of living in San Diego I have not yet encountered an illegal immigrant nor have I seen a discrepancy with an immigrant whether illegal or not. Considering I can see the fence and many gates that separate the borders of San Ysidro and Tijuana, it is not necessary to fund a multi-billion dollar wall.
Building a wall will not solve the illegal immigrant problem from Mexico. Just getting the rights to build the wall along with the cost of building the wall will present many challenges. The talks between Mexico and the United States about the wall have already begun to create a separation between the two countries. The astronomical cost of the wall is another reason why Building a wall will help solve many problems like illegal immigrants, drugs, guns, etc. And it will protect the United States from any the peril, and it has the effect on our demographic rate. Currently, we are in the top list for the threat of many other foreign countries and also building a wall will not only protect the country but also it will create the nation
The United States-Mexico border wall was proposed by Donald Trump at one of his rallies, assumingly as a way to get the crowd fired up, but he was serious. I don't believe that this is a good idea because it will do irreparable harm to both nations. This idea has many mixed reviews because I don't want the border shut down, I think it would be too expensive, and it will damage our international relations. This is why I believe that building the wall is a bad idea.
Michael Walzer’s Membership and Joseph Carens’s Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders present two strikingly different views on the justifiability of restrictions on immigration. In essence, Walzer argues that restrictions are generally justifiable, and Carens argues that they are not. In this essay, I will argue that Carens’s view is the more compelling one due to the following central reason: it promotes freedom of the individual. I will then apply Carens’s and Brown’s arguments to Donald Trump’s immigration policy, specifically his proposal to build a wall in order to keep immigrants from unlawfully entering the country. I will argue that this proposal is a marked move towards injustice and xenophobia disguised as an attempt to reclaim state sovereignty.