preview

Modern Tragedy Analysis

Good Essays

Is Modern Tragedy Truly Tragedy?
(A critique of Stephen King’s inspired movie The Green Mile as it relates to Aristotle’s Poetics)
“Tragedy is an imitation, not of men, but of an action and of life, and life consists in action, and its end is a mode of action, not a quality” (Butcher). Aristotle says that tragedy has more to do with the action of the plot than the characters themselves. Tragedy is best defined as a drama that includes a clear plot line and a protagonist who has a character flaw that leads to his or her downfall. Character flaws occur in many ways, for some it is excessive pride, for others it is just the need to be kind to others and disregarding a person’s own health. The major difference between a tragedy and a comedy is …show more content…

“The tragic hero, consequently, should be a man better than ourselves, but not perfect; and he should suffer from a flaw which shows itself in some mistaken judgement or act resulting in his downfall” (Poetics Packet). While it may not seem like a flaw, Coffey’s character “flaw” is that he has some sort of supernatural healing power which, in a way, got him into the death row area of prison to begin with. Coffey performs an act where he touches ill people and for whatever reason, the person is cured, and Coffey coughs up insects that represent the negative things leaving a person’s body as the individual heals. As the movie wraps up, Paul and various other guards are aware of John’s innocence, yet there is no evidence so he will have to be put to death regardless. Throughout the movie, men are put to death and the audience can see just how gruesome that is, yet people often feel little remorse or pity for the first several executions in the movie. The thing that is so emotional about John Coffey’s execution is that the viewers are aware he is being put to death even though he is innocent. “Virtually no one feels the urge to execute an innocent man, but many feel the urge to execute someone who is guilty” (Dow). That is a highly accurate statement, the majority of people have no issue killing a guilty person, but the real tearjerker is being

Get Access