In this essay I will be comparing Shakespeare’s original comedy text of ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ to the 2005 modern film adaption. The original text by William Shakespeare was created in 1598-1599, whereas the modern film adaption was created in 2005. The way people lived in the times when the two sources were created were very different. The original text, created in Elizabethan England was a time where woman had few rights and little freedom. The women were often “owned” by their fathers or husbands and subservient and inferior to them. There was an elite aristocracy where most of the population were working class/poor. In that time period people had a limited knowledge of the world and what they knew was heavily influenced by church and monarchy. The characters in Shakespeare’s version are like those of the people in the time it was created so it related to the lives of the audience of the play. The 2005 film adaption …show more content…
In both scenes Claudio/Claude accuses Hero of being unfaithful after being tricked into thinking so. The language used in the adapted film is similar and different to that in the text. If the Shakespearian insults were used in the film they’d sound ridiculous and not relate to a modern audience, however some are similar or a similar meaning, “rotten orange” and “rotten goods”. The way Hero reacts to this in both sources is very different. In the text Hero doesn’t speak up or defend herself as this is to relate to the time period it was written and portrays the nature of how women were “possessed” and are very different to how they are today. In the film adaption Hero defends herself and is independent and empowered as this relates more to modern women. Hero becomes the Heroine of the film and this emphasises the fact that she doesn’t want to be possessed, contradicting the original message of the text and making it
This essay is an exploration of the play Much Ado About Nothing, and the gender roles involved in the deceit and trickery that transpire and develop throughout the story. As gender is one of the main themes in the plot, identifying the expected gender roles of the characters, and how the contrast between characters highlights these expected roles. In Shakespeare 's time, known as the Elizabethan Era, men and women’s roles and expectations were starkly different. Elizabethan women, no matter what social class, were inferior to men. A female’s role in the family was to get married so they could increase their family 's wealth and power and to produce heirs. Men, on the other hand, had all of the power within a household. Males were expected
marriage women should be innocent, pure and faithful. Don John's plan to make Claudio think hero is unfaithful is a success which then Claudio, Don Pedro and Don John perceives Hero is unclean and impure.
On the other hand, the infrequent dialogue between Hero and Claudio could be seen as less interesting in terms of language. Hero doesn’t speak much – in fact she only speaks one line in the opening scene where she is present throughout- “My cousin (Beatrice) means Signor Benedick of Padua” (1.1.35) - this is to help the messenger understand what Beatrice has just said. It is also significant due to the fact that Hero only speaks in relation to Beatrice and Benedick, as can be seen by the quotation above.. Although it can be argued that the silence creates interest in the couple and that Hero’s silence is typical of traditional Elizabethan courtly love, this can be seen as unoriginal and stereotypical. Another part of the play that shows this is in Act Four, during her wedding. The number of lines she speaks is minimal, and where she does it is mysterious and can be seen in many ways. “One Hero died defiled, but I do live, and surely as I live, I am a maid.” (5.4.63).This
The patriarchal society is a setting of ‘Much Ado about Nothing’ that shows male domination and women suppression. Men like Don Pedro, Benedick and Claudio returns with victory from the battle. It implies the boasted male ego. Male honor serves as a crucial importance to men in the play. Leonato questions the messager that ‘How many gentlemen have you lost in this action?’ It hints that physical strength is a definition of manhood. With Don Pedro, Claudio and Benedick rise of power as a soldier with victory, they hold great power as a upper social class. In Act 1, the exposition of the play emphasize on men’s talk, only the outspoken Beatrice can have a word or two, but the men still dominate the
Throughout the history of the world, honor has been an important part of life. In literature, as well, honor plays an important role in many plots and the development of almost any character. Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing is no exception. In this comedy about love and marriage, honor is revealed as the primary reason for many of the actions taken by several different characters. When Claudio breaks off his wedding with Hero, he does it because he believes she is not chastised as she claims to be and in being such, she would dishonor him as well as her father if the marriage were to proceed as planned. The play is an accurate depiction of the honor code and the different standards for men and women of the time in regards to
Drama text, Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare is a romantic comedy revolved around marriage, dishonesty and love. In 2007, the original play had been interpreted and adapted into a new film text; Much Ado About Nothing Shakespeare Retold. This new film version is an adaption for the modern audience who’s views around love and marriage have changed since Elizabethan times. Brian Percival ‘Retold’ the original play, first published in 1623 by reinterpreting it into his own understanding of modern society with the focus of women’s roles nowadays. Whilst doing this Percival has maintained many of Shakespeare’s intentions.
“One woman is fair, yet I am well; another is wise, yet I am well; another virtuous, yet I am well; but till all graces be in one woman, one woman shall not come in my grace.” This quote, spoken by Benedick, completely describes the need for feminism, men wanting to “customize” their woman. The Shakespeare play Much Ado About Nothing is an early work of feminism because, it showed how women were held to a different sexual standard than men, that women were being told that they had to submit themselves to men, and that men wanted something perfect, when perfection doesn’t exist. Both male and female roles in the play help develop the feministic plot, and show those who are wrong, the right way.
The movie and the play “Much ado about nothing, despite of having the same name, each has its own characteristics that make them unique. As every theatrical work taken to the cinema many scenes were recreated differently, because it needs to be adapted to the preferences of the time in which the film is created in order to attract more public .Even the movie is based on the play ,they were created in different years so the audiences varies from one time to another. Also other reason is that movies need to adapt the story to a specific duration of time. For those that has seen the film and read the book ,Do the movie and the play reproduce exactly the same content? .Obviously the play and the movie have many similarities as the time in which
In William Shakespeare’s play Much Ado About Nothing, love has played a major rule as theme in this play. Shakespeare discussed different kinds of loving relationships; romantic love, family support and loyal friendship, and he shows how different characters react to love in many different ways. The main plot of Much Ado About Nothing is that of the relationship between Claudio and Hero, and the hidden love between Benedick and Beatrice. Similarly, deception is a big concept to consider as a theme in this play. Each of the main characters being the victim of deception; Shakespeare in this play shows that deception is not inherently evil, but can also be pure.
Much Ado About Nothing raises many important issues concerning the institution of marriage. Perhaps Shakespeare's purpose in writing this play was to question the existing approach to relationships and marriage. Shakespeare reveals the faults of the process through the characters of Hero and Claudio and also Hero's father, Leonato. Shakespeare also may be suggesting an alternative approach to marriage and relationships through the characters of Beatrice and Benedick.
The theme for honour and fidelity apply for both men and women in Shakespeare’s play ‘much ado about nothing’. Honour and fidelity is represented very differently for men and women as it would have been for the people in Elizabethan times. In this first section of the essay, I will be exploring double standards and Shakespeare’s awareness of the double standards between sexes and his feminist approach, the differences of honour and fidelity for men and women and upper class and lower class comparisons.
The humiliation caused to Hero in the event would be inconceivable to an audience at the time, being accused of adultery would no doubt ruin a woman’s reputation and therefore create difficulty for her when finding a husband; especially for a woman of high status such as Hero. Claudio is being presented as a potential threat at this part in the play, contrasting with the gallant war hero we were first introduced to. This emphasizes how bitter and sinister Claudio has turned, consequently reminding the audience by irony that is he only interested in wealth and status when marrying Hero. Claudio’s shallow fickleness plays into the villain’s hands. Shakespeare uses the threat of Claudio to generate further anxiety in the audience and concern for Hero’s welfare. This scene shows the men of the play coinciding with each other in their response to the defamation of Hero. Don Pedro personally insults Hero during the commotion of this scene, “to link my dear friend to a common stale,” he suggests here that he believes her status has been lowered by what she has supposedly done and rendered her ‘common’. This personal attack on Hero which has come from someone who shouldn’t really be involved advocates the idea that she is isolated in a patriarchal society in which men group together to defend male interests. Hero’s reputation is being publicly ruined here, and at the time this would have ruined Hero’s life and her
In Shakespeare’s Much Ado about Nothing, there are the usual characters that show up in most of Shakespeare’s pieces. For instance the characters Hero and Claudio could easily be compared to Romeo and Juliet. Both Hero and Juliet are innocent, quite, and beautiful young women who fall in love instantly without conversing with the other person. Likewise, Claudio and Romeo decide to marry these women within twenty-four hours. Because of these characters’ lack of unique and interesting qualities, I
Whedon sets Much Ado About Nothing solely on the estate of Leonato, a spacious, contemporary house along with the land around it. The metaphoric use of the estate’s inside versus the estate’s outside within the film gives the audience a subliminal layer of understanding of the conflicts between characters. Inside the house, the family and guests carry out domestic life: lighthearted bickering such as Benedick and Claudio’s gamesome fight, planning events and other civil tasks like the party planning and Hero and Claudio’s wedding plans, as well as Benedick and Beatrice being fooled and falling in love, the majority of comedic relief. Outdoors, still on the estate, the conflict mainly occurs. Frequently, turmoil and misconception lead the
Kenneth Branagh’s 1993 film of Much Ado About Nothing is a British and American romantic comedy, based on William Shakespeare’s renowned production. In sixteenth century Messina, Sicily set on and around Governor Leonato’s estate, villains are outwitted, lovers wed and dancing concludes an underlining major conflict, ‘ado about nothing.’ Suspicion of a deceived wedding, in which husbands are obliged to be controlled and betrayed, but also greatly desire to be married. Branagh employs visual humour through fundamental themes, recurring motifs and symbols, which exemplify abstract ideas, or concepts. Thus, this assists to emphasise the significance of Shakespeare’s dialogue throughout specific scenes in the adaptation.