preview

Much Ado About Nothing Film Analysis

Good Essays

In this essay I will be comparing Shakespeare’s original comedy text of ‘Much Ado About Nothing’ to the 2005 modern film adaption. The original text by William Shakespeare was created in 1598-1599, whereas the modern film adaption was created in 2005. The way people lived in the times when the two sources were created were very different. The original text, created in Elizabethan England was a time where woman had few rights and little freedom. The women were often “owned” by their fathers or husbands and subservient and inferior to them. There was an elite aristocracy where most of the population were working class/poor. In that time period people had a limited knowledge of the world and what they knew was heavily influenced by church and monarchy. The characters in Shakespeare’s version are like those of the people in the time it was created so it related to the lives of the audience of the play. The 2005 film adaption …show more content…

In both scenes Claudio/Claude accuses Hero of being unfaithful after being tricked into thinking so. The language used in the adapted film is similar and different to that in the text. If the Shakespearian insults were used in the film they’d sound ridiculous and not relate to a modern audience, however some are similar or a similar meaning, “rotten orange” and “rotten goods”. The way Hero reacts to this in both sources is very different. In the text Hero doesn’t speak up or defend herself as this is to relate to the time period it was written and portrays the nature of how women were “possessed” and are very different to how they are today. In the film adaption Hero defends herself and is independent and empowered as this relates more to modern women. Hero becomes the Heroine of the film and this emphasises the fact that she doesn’t want to be possessed, contradicting the original message of the text and making it

Get Access