preview

Not Schools Are Teaching Kids To Think Analysis

Decent Essays

It appears traditional teaching methods in many schools across the nation are undergoing significant changes, mostly due to the technological world we live in, and if this does not concern you, it should. It is not only that printing has replaced cursive writing; spell check has replaced the dictionary, or researching any topic has become a relatively easy task with Internet availability, the effects of these changes go much deeper. While there is no harm in saving time and using different or more profound methods that surely have made our lives easier, the simple fact is these things are mechanical advances made from computer technology, but they will never replace a person’s brain, analytical thinking skills and thought processes. Computers …show more content…

Someone has to teach the ABC’s and the 123’s that get a person through life, or do they? There is science, history and English to contend with also. At any given time in life, you will undoubtedly have to sign a contract, take out a loan, or possibly even bail yourself out of jail, so it would be a huge asset if you could read, write and comprehend effectively. But, according to James Paul Gee author of Games, Not Schools, Are Teaching Kids to Think, “The US spends almost 50 billion each year on education, but Forty percent of students lack basic reading skills, and their academic performance is dismal compared with that of their foreign counterparts”. (Gee 399) Obviously the method many schools are using is not working upholding Carr’s theory that we are turning into more of a pancake society. Gee reports that presently schools are using a mechanical scripted instruction method that is merely teaching by way of line by line scripting resulting in students memorizing material and subsequently participating in a barrage of multiple choice testing. This does not necessarily mean that memorization does not have a place in education, it …show more content…

They’re learning to learn.” (Gee, 399) Gee might be correct that there is potential to learn through video gaming, however, it is more the content of these games that should be held up to scrutiny. Specifically, the depth of violence and unrealistic virtual worlds involved in many of these games should indeed hold cause for concern. There are no long term studies to draw from telling us that video gaming is either a good or bad thing. But we do have common sense to draw from and we should consider what is known to date from both ends of the spectrum. The popular television show Dr. Phil recently aired an episode when a young man was so addicted to video gaming that it overtook his life. He no longer ate, showered or brushed his teeth and only slept when it physically overtook him. He mentally transformed himself into the video game, ignoring everything else. While this may be only one case, it should not be ignored. When considering the theories both Carr and Gee present, both essays are alarming and brings one not only to the conclusion that education is definitely in crisis in this country, but if were intending on video games to fill some kind of educational void, we are likely a country in

Get Access