Rough Outline:
Fill in the outline below. Draft due 2/26
1. INTRO
a. Argument: Freed African-Americans could consider the Reconstruction a partial failure because while it secured basic rights for African Americans, they were still not socially, legally, or economically equal to the white citizens.
a. Time: 1865-1888
b. Place: United States Southern States
c. Topic: Effect of Reconstruction
2. Body Paragraph One – Topic 1: Voting was a right African Americans earned during Reconstruction, but with social and legal tension this was a right that was almost impossible to achieve for most; leaving them legally unequal.
a. Evidence 1: The 15th amendment guaranteed the right to vote for African Americans, promising any man that was a citizen
…show more content…
Evidence 2: Laws like the Poll tax and Literacy tests kept freedmen out of the stands by forcing unreasonable questions and qualities onto them. (Textbook pg. 568)
i. Analysis 2: As white southern Democrats were the founders of these laws, they were made to restrict the voices of the freedmen in government as they thought it was wrong. This kept the government as a “White Man’s Government” and limited the actual right from the 15th amendment.
e. Evidence 3: White supremacy groups like the Ku Klux Klan and the White League also kept black voters out of the stands by enforcing violence and sometimes even murder to keep their views as the reality. (doc. D, Textbook Pg. --)
i. Analysis 3: The Ku Klux Klan and the White League believed that a freedman having a voice in government was wrong, as did most of the white Southern population. To enforce their beliefs, these to white supremacist groups used violence and even murder to drive African-Americans from the polls.
3. Body Paragraph Two - Topic 2: Freedmen and women could consider Reconstruction a partial failure because while black citizens were now paid for their service, obtaining a job and earning equal pay as a white brother was a strenuous task which left them economically
…show more content…
Analysis 1: While southern Democrats did not believe in paying labor for blacks, there were people out there besides the black citizens fighting for the black’s rights and trying to make a change. They took time to explain and put into place labor systems that rewarded the African Americans with the pay they deserved and that made a change in the South.
f. Evidence 2: Even when they have the exact same job as a white citizen, African-Americans most always got paid significantly less than the white citizens working beside him/her. (Doc. E)
g. Analysis 2: This was not the amount African-Americans deserved for the duties they provided, but because of discrimination this was the norm in the South. White bosses of black citizens paid them entirely on what color their skin was, instead of how well they worked.
h. Evidence 3: Augustus Straker, an African-American lawyer noted that blacks often got as little as 15 cents a day, or a total of six to eight dollars a month. (Doc. E)
i. Analysis 3: This only sometimes barely got African-Americans through day-to-day life and usually left them with little to spend on anything but the necessities, leaving them poor and having to take on more work so they could provide for their families as well as
During Reconstruction, African Americans’ freedoms were very restricted. There were strict regulations on voting, relationships, employment, firearms, and other freedoms that white people had. African American faced disenfranchisement for years after being freed and becoming citizens. In What a Black Man Wants by Frederick Douglass, Douglass angrily demands the freedom to vote that every American deserved. He assesses the black man’s contribution to society and wonders why this contribution has not led to more rights. Those who were supposed to be fighting for the rights of freed slaves were not speaking up. Even the Massachusetts Anti-Slavery Society was not fighting for the rights of the freed slaves. Because of the restrictions on voting, African Americans did not have the same power over their own lives that white people had. Disenfranchisement is just one way white people limited freedoms of freed slaves.
Reconstruction was a time period of major change in the United States of America for both African Americans and White citizens. After the Civil War, the reconstruction process started out as a failure, but over the years turned into a huge success because of how African Americans were able to live normal lives. Overall, Reconstruction was a success because freedom and growth of equality for African Americans was increased greatly.
In conclusion, African Americans were denied of their amendments and whites were racist towards them. African Americans were not free even though they had rights that they could live
The right to vote for African American became difficult during the time because the northern didn’t want to consider the blacks as equal to the society. As Frederick Douglass, has once stated “Slavery is not abolished until the black man has the ballot.” African American fought their way to gain their right to vote is by coming together, free blacks and emancipated slaves, to create parades, petition drives to demand, and to organize their own “freedom ballots.” As a free African American, they except the same respect as the whites and nothing
“I gave a little blood on that bridge in Selma, Alabama for the right to vote. I’m not going to stand by and let the Supreme Court take the right to vote away from us [African Americans]” –John Lewis. Within 100 years, African Americans overcame many obstacles such as paying poll taxes, passing multiple tests, and violence to be able to vote. They had to pay taxes, such as poll taxes. They also had to pass multiple tests, such as the Property and Literacy tests. Violence was also an obstacle African Americans had to face in order to vote.
Following the American Civil War, the bloodiest armed conflict on US soil, slavery had been outlawed from the US. It had taken the US until January 31, 1865, less than two-hundred years ago, for slavery to be abolished. Yet, it was still abolished, albeit, later than many other nations throughout the world. It had taken yet over another year for the fourteenth amendment to be passed in June 13, 1866, making all former slaves into citizens. But, perhaps the greatest and most important right of all, the right essential to any democracy or republic, the right to vote, was given to former slaves through the fifteenth amendment.
Throughout America’s history the franchise has been withheld from different groups. This has been possible due to weakly written laws that do not provide adequate protections. In 1965 PL 89-110 was passed, this law, commonly known as the Voting Rights Act of 1965, finally provided real protections for minorities living in southern states. In recent years the language of the law was modified within the Supreme Court to take away the law’s primary power. In the following mock Congressional testimony we will go back to 1848, 13 years before the American Civil War, and provide evidence of why a law like PL 89-110 is necessary and commendable.
The emancipation proclamation was what seemed like the beginning of freedom for African Americans. African Americans fought hard and valiantly in the American Civil war and with the Unions win freedom and peace for blacks seemed to be assured. As most people would quote," Freedom isn 't free." It almost always has a cost. Africans Americans since the origin of this country have literally laid down their lives for the cost of freedom and opportunity in the US. One of the most coveted freedom 's both past and present is the right to suffrage. My paper discusses the many factors leading to and the trials and tribulations involving black 's right to vote. In this paper, I will discuss the constitutional amendments as well as the landmark supreme court cases that affected both the lives and voting rights of African Americans during the time period of 1865 through 1900.
“The Voting Rights Act of 1965 is a landmark piece of federal legislation in the United States that prohibits racial discrimination in voting.” In the 1880’s poll taxes and literacy requirements that afterward advocated African Americans to vote. Meanwhile Klan violence frightens from police and employers, blacks were still “protesting”about voting rights. As a result, there were over two dozen blacks serving in state congress across some
In hindsight it is sometimes claimed that Reconstruction was a failure. Although there was some good that came out of the Reconstruction it was mostly just a relentless uphill battle against Southerners and immoral politicians that were here to delay change and keep racism alive. Reconstruction brought the Ku Klux Klan who displayed great resistance, and poverty that swept the South once the blacks were freed. The freedom of these black slaves led to discriminatory legislatures such as the Black Codes and the Jim Crow laws to keep the blacks constrained from actually being free. The South was then encountered with corruption and high property taxes, as a rebuild was in order to reestablish the war torn part of the nation.
So in basic sense what Douglas was forced to say, Reconstruction failed. It did not permanently guaranteed the basic rights of the former slaves. Writing in the 1930s, W.E.B Du Bois in “Black Reconstruction In America” used an interesting phrase, “a splendid failure”. Why splendid? He said it failed, but not for the reason most white people expected to fail, the incapacity of the former slaves. It actually demonstrated their capacity for freedom, for citizenship, for participation in democracy, things widely denied in 1865, and in fact still denied when Du Boise was writing in the
Even after the Civil War ended, African Americans were still having a very tough time being an equal part of society., which shows that Reconstruction failed socially.
African-Americans may sometimes wonder at the contradictory facts about their history presented in many standard history texts. These texts state that blacks were given the right to vote in 1870, yet the same texts will acknowledge that this right did not really exist for African-Americans until the Civil Rights Movement of the 1960s.
The Passing of the 15th amendment in 1868 did give black men the right to vote. They were able to vote but were not permitted because they were blocked at the poles with threats of violence and death. The violence and intimidation of the Ku Klux Klan had a lot to do with the blocking of the blacks at the voting polls.
Many of these Americans have a set idea and mentality that blacks deserve less. As Borbely explained I would have to agree with him. I believe that in order for equal pay for both whites and blacks who have all worked the same should be treated equally. I have a good feeling that whites want to remain on top only so that they can have the power and self satisfying feel. That way they know that things go their way or no way at all. I want to believe that one day everyone will come to the realization that we are all the same and that it is just the shade of my skin that separates us. However, in reality whites will always feel that they have the upper hand for they are treated better and they are allowed to also get away with much more. From what I’ve seen in my experiences, whites are set up in life to succeed no matter what they do. If they fail, they will be seen as someone who’s tried hard but just needs a push. If they make a mistake then it’s okay because everyone makes mistakes. If they commit a crime, most times due to the corrupted system they are either let go or punished easily. As if it was to be a black person, then they will be treated harsher for they should know better; and are not allowed to make mistakes. It’s not okay for them to need assistance. Overall, society placed levels of tolerance and levels of expectations for everyone and for blacks it 's been set at an all time low preventing them from at times attempting to prove otherwise.