preview

Premodern Childhood

Decent Essays

The interest in the examination of childhood as a scholastic field was sparked by the seminal work of medievalist historian Philippe Ariès (1914-84). Ariès suggests that premodern childhood was a time of neglect and abuse since high mortality rates prevented people from forging close bonds with their children. It is for this reason, children were thought as being at the bottom of the social scale and therefore unworthy of consideration. Ariès can be quoted as saying from his 1962 pioneering publication Centuries of Childhood “….that in a premodern age, especially that before the seventeenth century, that childhood did not exist. In a medieval society, the “idea” of childhood did not exist…[the] awareness of the particular nature which distinguishes …show more content…

These theories are reinforced by the impression that during this period, children were modeled to be “little adults”; viewed nothing more than economic assets as opposed to symbols of love. This can be seen visually throughout the sixteenth-century in portraiture of children with their parents, who were stylized similarly to their parents and/or depicted to possess adult-like features. While Ariès work is viewed as a principle text in the studies of childhood, Italian Renaissance scholars such as Linda Pollock, Louis Haas, Jacqueline Mussachio, and Christiane Klapisch-Zuber refute these claims, stating that “…childhood was viewed as a discrete part of domestic life, portioned off from adulthood; as a time of innocence and play; a stage in life in which a child is shielded by parents to the harsh realities of adulthood”. Alberti’s Quattro libri della famiglia and Louis Haas’ 1998 book The Renaissance Man and his children: Childbirth and Early Childhood in Renaissance Florence 1300-1600 both seem to concede to Ariès’ claims, but Mussachio, Linda Pollock’s Forgotten Children: Parent-Child relations from 1500-1900, and Christiane Klapisch-Zuber’s 1987 publication Women, Family, and Ritual in Renaissance Italy point out numerous issues with

Get Access