preview

Reflection On Persistent Whiggism And The Reformation

Better Essays

Response Paper #1 Christianity and the Reformation “Reflections on Persistent Whiggism and Its Antidotes in the Study of Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-century Intellectual History Richard A. Muller’s “Reflection on Persistent Whiggism and Its Antidotes” presents Muller’s argument regarding recent methods of study of the Reformation. Whiggism refers to not simply a party, but an idea of progressivism that projects itself upon the past. I like to use the word lens to describe this phenomena as the research being critiqued is viewing the past through the lens of modern thought. Muller also offers ways to reform this system for a more accurate study of the Reformation. He gives five main issues, and systematically describes the problems with each one, with supporting historical examples. He also gives further insight into how the Reformation ought to be studied in order to …show more content…

Instead of being looked at through the historical context to help us understand the motives and theology of the Reformation, often the Reformation is looked at through a modern understanding of what this time period looked like. Muller encourages historians to use contextual vocabulary to describe and understand the time period in which these men shared their ideas in order to more fully and accurately understand them. An example he uses is looking to historical dictionaries and texts to help understand readings in their context and what they meant during the time they were written in order to extricate the authors’ true intent. Furthermore, Muller talks about the importance of properly placing people and ideas within their historical and intellectual context. This shows the linkage between thought and ideology of the time and the implications and radicalism not from the perspective of modern thinkers, but in the context of the time and society in which these men

Get Access