A Modest Proposal: How to Twist a Fictional Proposal and Make it Convincing
Have you ever imagined what it would be like to eat a one-year child, whether stewed, roasted, or freshly baked? Perhaps you could have the chance for that unique experience, if you were English, living around the time period, when Jonathan Swift wrote his essay “A Modest Proposal” in 1729. The main purpose of his satirical essay was to capture the attention to the problems that were experienced by the Irish people, especially at that time when the English were imposing severe taxes on them. He proposed that Irish infants could be sold as food at age one, where a young healthy one-year child would be delicious and wholesome food. He offered many advantages for his scheme; for Irish, to decrease the burden and charges upon Irish parents, to prevent voluntary abortions, and to give them a new source of income; for English, they would benefit from a new food product, and at the long run, to eliminate a social problem and reduce the number of Catholics in Ireland.
In “A Modest Proposal”, Swift effectively used his sarcasm, irony and rhetorical exaggeration to both persuade, and deceive the readers for his clear, and undeclared telos (purposes), accompanied with his perfect usage of ethos, pathos and logos to support his immodest fictional proposal.
At first glance, Swift convinced the reader of his sympathy towards poor people, “It is a melancholy... .These mothers…are forced to employ…for their helpless
Swift begins his essay by describing walking down a street in Ireland. He describes how you would see, “beggars of the female sex, followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags, and importuning every passenger for an alms” (Swift, Para. 1). This gives the reader a mental
Desperate times often call for desperate measures, and proposals of desperate measures are often met with swift criticism if they are found to be without rational thought and merit. It is unlikely that anyone in their right mind would consider, for any amount of time, the proposal of rearing children, or properly raising them, as food to help alleviate poverty-stricken Ireland in 1729. Yet, Jonathan Swift’s suggestion was satirical brilliance, and it was a modest proposal for illuminating the cause of Ireland’s woes. The proposal was not actually eating children but placing a mirror for the reader to reflect upon. The target audience of landlords, gentlemen, and other people of stature were more than accustomed to stepping on the poor on
Irony is a beautiful technique exercised to convey a message or call a certain group of people to action. This rhetorical skill is artfully used by Jonathan Swift in his pamphlet “A Modest Proposal.” The main argument for this mordantly ironic essay is to capture the attention of a disconnected and indifferent audience. Swift makes his point by stringing together a dreadfully twisted set of morally untenable positions in order to cast blame and aspersions on his intended audience. Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” employs despicably vivid satire to call for change in a world of abuse and misfortune.
In Jonathan Swift’s satire, “A Modest Proposal”, Swift writes about the starving people of Ireland in the early 1700’s. He makes a wild and absurd proposal to help remedy the problems of overpopulation and poverty. Swift wants to make a political statement by using the “children” as satire to grasp the attention of the audience - the English people, the Irish politicians and the rich – and make them aware of the political, moral, and social problems. In “A Modest Proposal”, Swift’s arguments are presented effectively by using pathos (emotional appeal), ethos (ethics and values), and logos (logic reasoning and facts).
The sarcastic views of Swift’s understanding of the poverty of Ireland leads him to make a proposal for a solution to poverty, where he ignores the concern of human morale by displaying the lacking efforts of England to help. Swift uses methods that work to get or help better understand a situation, for example being sarcastic in a situation where a person wants something out of the situation by satire. The undeniable effect of satire catches the attention of England to further display the poverty of Ireland which is displayed throughout Swift’s Modest Proposal with exaggeration, incongruity and reversal.
Like the other numerous number of circulating pamphlets, Swift’s ‘A Modest Proposal’ begins with a sympathetic description of poor Irish people who can’t afford raising their kids to give one a sense of sympathy towards them. Unlike the other pamphlets of his contemporaries which proposed remedies or just complained about the problem like how the British government did, he emphasizes that his proposal “…is of a much greater extent, and shall take in the whole number of infants at a certain age who are
Johnathan Swift published a book called A Modest Proposal. A Modest Proposal is about the impoverished Irish and that they might ease their economic troubles by selling their children as food for rich gentlemen and ladies. The problem in the story is their economy is failing and they don’t know how to fix it. So, they go to the idea of eating and selling children because they are running out of food.
Jonathan Swift, the writer of the satirical essay A Modest Proposal, grew up and lived in Ireland during times of famine and economic struggles (Conditions). Growing up with a single mother and no father, Swift knew what hard times and struggles were like (Jonathan Swift: Biography). His essay proposes an easy solution to the economic problems going on in Ireland for both the wealthy ruling classes and the poorer classes, although his intentions and the meaning behind his words are not what would be originally thought when initially reading the essay. Through his word choices and the description of specific events of his time, Swift uses satire to grab his audience’s attention and get his own personal ideas and opinions out about all the
In ‘A Modest Proposal’ the author, Jonathan Swift utilizes techniques such as satire, sarcasm, and irony to create a bigger picture to the reader. Within the poem, Swift not only presents a humorous approach to social and economic issues but does so in a well-constructed and carefully composed manner. A closer reading of the text reveals a deeper critical analysis of the social perceptions of the poor at the time. Through Swifts’ use of irony, he creates a proposal that is so extremely absurd that some may believe the piece to be genuine. By taking an issue and providing a corrupt and merciless solution, the writer uses a unique approach to catch the attention of the people of Ireland and presents them a proposal they cannot ignore. Through the use of irony, Swift creates a poem that not only criticizes social perceptions of the poor but also remarks upon the issue without directly addressing the reader.
Indirectly, the ideals from Bacon’s, The Four Idols, is agreeable with the pamphlet, A Modest Proposal, due to the false notions people believe in society. The tone of Swift efficiently lets him get his message across, while Bacon’s idea came across directly and upfront. Even with Swift giving advice to all, the ironic event is Swift came out with this pamphlet anonymously because he knew of the consequence afterwards like stated in the “Idols of the Marketplace.” All in all, Swift’s opinions regarding how individuals need to believe in the true notions of others, directly correlates with the beliefs Bacon stated in The Four
Irony is a beautiful technique exercised to convey a message or call a certain group of people to action. This rhetorical skill is artfully used by Jonathan Swift in his pamphlet “A Modest Proposal.” The main argument for this bitingly ironic essay is to capture the attention of a disconnected and indifferent audience. Swift makes his point by stringing together a dreadfully twisted set of morally untenable positions in order to cast blame and aspersions on his intended audience. Jonathan Swift’s “A Modest Proposal” employs despicably vivid satire to call for change in a world of abuse and misfortune.
Jonathan Swift, in his essay “A Modest Proposal”, effectively utilizes an extended metaphor in order to convey his message that we must take action against widespread poverty. The satirical point employed suggests that poor children be eaten in order to decrease the surplus population, and is efficacious due to the fact that in such a terrible state of affairs, cannibalism can be logically defended as a viable solution. Swift’s essay, written in 1729, clearly precedes the existing social programs in effect throughout much of the first world. However, the ominous reality is that Swift’s essay can just as effectively be used as a comparison, albeit a figurative one, to modern day society, if our current welfare spending continues.
While lacing his work with an old, familiar style Swift injected his own unique flair in his pamphlet as well. In A Modest Proposal paragraphs frequently start with sympathetic, almost dreamlike, idealizations and end, metaphorically, with a knife to the gut. Swift entices the reader with his sympathetic voice then delivers such biting wit the reader is stunned and taken aback. Another trick used by Swift is a redirection technique. Major points are intentionally separated to redirect readers to Swift’s important views and enforce his ideas. In A Modest Proposal Swift uses the end of the pamphlet to restate all previous notions. This gives the reader not only a refresher but another chance to analyze the true meaning.
“Satire is a sort of glass, wherein beholders do generally discover everybody’s face but their own” (Swift). Such beholders, as Jonathan Swift astutely emphasizes, are intended, through guidance of satiric narrative, to recognize social or political plights. In some satires, as in Swift’s own A Modest Proposal, the use of absurd, blatant exaggeration is intended to capture an indolent audience’s attention regarding the social state of the poor. Yet even in such a direct satire, there exists another layer of meaning. In regards to A Modest Proposal, the interchange between the voice of the proposer and Swift’s voice introduces another medium of criticism, as well as the opportunity for readers to reflect on how well they may fit the
“Do you need to earn fast, easy money? Try selling your babies!” No matter when they lived, any sane person reading this would immediately recoil in disgust. However, Jonathan Swift used this absurd, satirical proposal to point out the flaws within his own society of the English and the Irish Catholic in the late 17th century. Throughout his life, Swift faced rejection from those he desired to please. Jonathan Swift’s alienation from an early age, caused by his suffering from Meniere’s disease and his periodical physical separation from the rest of society, allowed Swift to showcase in his “Modest Proposal” how damaging the alienation and mistreatment of an individual can be, as well as flaws in human thinking and reasoning in his work Gulliver’s Travels.