Russia Bill Of Rights Essay

A comparison between the U.S. constitution and Russian constitution is interesting due to the fact that America is often regarded (at least from the view of most Americans) as the pinnacle of freedom and democracy. The Russian Federation on the other hand has a much more complex image. The Russian Federation was formerly a country known as the Soviet Union, which was the pinnacle of communism throughout the 1900’s. Communism is a polar governmental structure compared to the U.S. The Russian Federation is today classified as a democracy, however, there are still remnants of the communist structure seen among leaders as a result of the way that the constitution is constructed.

Russian federation has struggled with human rights, it works tirelessly to give all humans equal opportunities. The constitution of Russian federation and the federal

During the Communist regime in the former Soviet Union, life was very difficult. The people who lived within the countries controlled by the Soviet government experienced levels of oppression akin to slavery. They could not express themselves through any means and had to conform both body and soul to the views of the Communist Party. People could be arrested, imprisoned, shipped off to exile or executed often without trial. Some twenty million people died while Joseph Stalin led the USSR and for many years after his death it was still dangerous to dare criticize his regime, although some scholars put that number closer to forty million people who died. Now that the Soviet Union has broken up and Russia is its own country there is more freedom, but the people still live under the yoke of an oppressive leader who does not tolerate political or social challenges. The people do nothing to stand up to this government because they have all been scarred by the decades they lived under Stalin.

The Kremlin does not take kindly to any who would question its authority, whether through speech, essays, or social media. In fact, all protests except those authorized by the government are illegal. Another example of their censorship is visible in 2015 when the Kremlin attempted to disconnect Russia’s internet from that of the rest of the world in order to close the country from outside influences (Soldatov 396). The reason for such adamancy on the subject of censorship is due to the fact that Russian authorities have reimplemented their repressive tactics towards opponents since Vladimir Putin’s presidential reelection in 2012 (Gel’den 7). The Kremlin bases its success off of the extent of control it can exert. Thus, the breeding ground of ideas that is the internet is dangerous to their objectives. While it is impossible to completely shut the country off from external influences at the moment, Russia is definitely capable of stifling domestic opposition; especially that of the people

The U.S Constitution and the Bill of Rights are iconic pieces of American History. These two documents are very important for every American to know and to read critically because it can highly affect them. However, there are many people in the country that do not know what is exactly in these documents. I have read through these pieces, and I will be discussing what I found to be most surprising to find in the piece. Also, the items that I expected to find in the documents that is not there.

The main function of law-enforcement agencies in Russia is not to protect the public from crime and corruption, but to shield the bureaucracy, including themselves, from the public” . The Russian police have been accused of getting paid to carry out jobs that benefit the image of the government. Both police forces are accused of using unnecessary force to complete corrupt motives. In Russia those who want to protest the government may have a tough time trying to come out without any injuries. An article from the New York time says “Many Russians seem to feel that they do not have much recourse in the face of police abuse and a result, motorists’ rights groups have sprung up. In October last year, The New York Times profiled a leader of one such group in Yekaterinburg, who was beaten in police custody after protesting corruption” . After protesting that the government was corrupt the leader was beaten and thrown in jail. This is evident that the police are there to protect the image of the government and if someone speaks out against the government they are liable to be victims of police brutality. This is similar to the cases of police brutality that occur in the United States, which have been connected to systematic discrimination. With the many protest that occur in the U.S, countless have been in result of police brutality cases against blacks. Most of the protest end with protesters being

Now America is the complete opposite from Russia. In America everyone knows that they have the right to speak out without having the fear of being disciplined. Bill of rights Institute states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances” (Bill of rights Institute). This is the first amendment of the bill of rights, it is their because citizens wanted a warranty of their basic freedoms. Without this protesters could be silenced, the press could not criticize government, and citizens could not inspire for social change. Then there is United States Courts stating “Congress shall make no law...abridging freedom of speech.”(US Courts). America is not making or has not made any laws that keep civilians from talking out and stating what is on their mind. Without this protesters could be silenced, the press could not criticize government, and citizens could not inspire for social change. Thankfully for the 1st amendment in the bill of rights everyone knows that they have the right to talk and express what they feel even if it is about the

My answer is this. No. They don’t. Since 2000 and Vladimir Putin’s election Russia has become more authoritarian, he has gotten away with this through massive economic growth, increased living standards and a much better lifestyle. The Russian government these days openly rigs elections (2011), seizes oligarchs property and assets (Mikhail Khodorkovsky), assassinated journalists (Anna Politkovskaya) and defectors (Alexander Litvinenko) and has passed laws banning homosexual propaganda. Every one of these actions has gone against what I fought for in the Soviet Union. However there are even more violations against what I stood for; today all of Russia’s major companies are state owned and the Russian government is taking over all sectors of the economy, notably agriculture and technology companies, which is completely against economic liberalisation, an idea that I believe is pivotal to a country and its people as it closes the gap of wealth inequality. Modern day Russia is a perfect example of economic inequality, with 110 individuals (Oligarchs) owning 35% of Russia’s wealth. This is worse than Soviet days and I have always pushed for wealth distribution. Furthermore, the Russian government has taken it upon itself to ban women from certain jobs (that are for men) and also it has become more prominent than ever the assassination and silencing of thousands of activists across Russia. However, the recurring theme here is that government is the one continually interfering in the day to day lives of ordinary citizens. It is also very simple why. So that it retains its power and its control of power. So, therefore the biggest opposition and threat to human rights in Russia and as a matter of fact for the whole world is governments. Governments that are corrupt and take and do not

The two, however are quite similar. In Russia, there are extremely harsh punishments for disobeying the law, there are forced labour camps in Siberia for their criminals and North Korean criminals. Political opponents are eliminated immediately, either locked up in jail, sent to a forced labour camp or executed, which is why Putin has served for eighteen years. Like Oceania, Russia is also the biggest country in the world, although most of it is uninhabited. Surveillance, though, is somewhat relaxed, with one CCTV camera having to monitoring every seven hundred and twenty one people.

Russia has been recognized for torturing people through the Cold War, the KGB, and tyrants. Putin has many malevolent deaths written under his name and the killing of people is torture because one is “inflicting severe pain on someone” (Merriam-Webster). As proof of the bodies built up in a ten year period, Putin has chosen to execute at least ten activist fighting him to keep them silent (JNCG). These deaths infringe on the right of freedom from cruel and unusual punishment because the act of causing death is, by law, cruel. Moreover, Putin sent a human right defender to death, “in June 2011 two unidentified men severely beat Bakhrom Hamroev… a leading Russian human rights group—in his Moscow apartment building” (World Report 2012). The human right defender was helping people go to court against Putin for torture and deaths he has caused at the time when Hamroev died. Beatings are generally part of prisoners’ lives to get information out of them, however in this case it is for the use to keep Hamroev silent. On the other hand, the KGB participates in the culture torture; recently a torture house became open to the public to expose the culture of Russia in 2014 (Presser). People such as, Putin and the KGB, are calling torture part of Russian culture to be able to permit opening of torture houses as historical landmarks. However, it is part of the

The Russian LGBT Network has been helping gay men escape and flee from Russia into a safer country. However, many of the men trying to escape persecution in Chechnya are being denied US visas, turning them back and making them walk back into their own death trap. This is not right, and there needs to be action taken to help these men. Chechnya needs to be held responsible, they are breaking basic human rights by persecuting people for doing nothing but be

Homophobia is transporting Russia back in time to the late 1800s and early 1900s—the epoch of the racial issues in America. With several gay rights being legalized, it seemed that Russia had begun to accept the LGBT community into their society. But the violent and repressive actions towards gay people and their supporters have proved that Russia is not becoming any more tolerant of gays. It is unsure if Russians even view gays as humans. The present status of the Russian homophobia problem is starting to spiral out of control. Given Russia’s oscillating history with the LGBT community, it’s nearly impossible to predict whether or not Russia will accept or kill the gay people. Based on the current situation, it seems like the former will

Over the past few years, they have been creating and getting rid of some of their laws against the LGBT+ community. While the ones they have gotten rid of were harsh towards them, the new laws they have created are unmannerly. “The gay propaganda law they have in Russia helps/ encourages homophobia, this law is to help protect their children, saving their morals and health.” ( BBC News ) While this can be proving their point to show children more traditional ways, doing this creates a barrier between them and the outside world. They are trying to “protect” these children's minds yet they are being ill-mannered to those that they are protecting their kids from. “The way this law has been applied shows that it is not aimed at protecting minors, but at removing LGBT people, an enormous social

When we hear the term Russian culture many Americans tend to have negative thoughts like the cold war, their government ruling with an iron hand, and the Red Scare. These thoughts do not do the justice to the Russian people or to their long history as a people dating back to INSERT DATE. One of the major themes throughout Russian history and this course is the idea that the Russian people value intangible things more than the tangible. The Russian people have a long rich heritage, they are deep in there Christian faith, and they pride themselves on hospitality and value there community, families, and fellow Russian people. They have learned how to sacrifice from the constant invasions and being forced farther and

Russia, known by most as the Russian Federation, is a federal state in Eurasia. Russia is the largest country in the world at 17,075,200 square kilometres by surface area, covering more than one eighth of Earth 's inhabited land, and the ninth most populous, with over 146.6 million people as of end of March 2016. The European western part of the country is much more populated and urbanised than the East, with almost eight-tenths of the population living within the European region of Russia. Russia 's capital, Moscow is one of the largest cities in Europe and the world. Its ohter major urban cities include Saint Petersburg, Novosibirsk, Yekaterinburg, Nizhny Novgorod and Samara.