preview

Scarlet Letter Bad Vs Good

Decent Essays

The differences between good and bad are easy to recognize for nearly everyone. Naturally humans are able to decipher from right and wrong, regardless of how they plan to react to such information, it is a given that they at least can recognize the classification before reacting to it. Occasionally, we are exposed to situations in which two opposite things, like right and wrong, are sewn together to exist in a paradox. In his book, “The Scarlet Letter”, Nathaniel Hawthorne creates complexity by infusing in both Hester Prynne and her scarlet letter an appearance contradictory of their reputation which complicates the reader’s ability to firmly decipher between good and bad and confuses the senses in forcing the audience to question where their …show more content…

This effect is first achieved in illustrating the contrast between Hester sunny appearance and the expectations surrounding her dark crime. She boldly yet unintentionally goes against all societal norms and predetermined expectations of the time. In reference to her reputation, she is an outcast and a sinner, having committed the crime of adultery. Having this label, unique among the remainder of the town, the reader anticipates Prynne to be a dark, villainous outcast but Hawthorne describes her as elegant, lady-like, and having hair, “so glossy it threw off the sunshine with a gleam” (47). The image of her (hair) being so bright and radiant that she could throw about beams of sunshine perfectly contradicts the expectation coupled with her crime. This dark versus light, or good versus bad appears again in Hawthorne’s description of how the townsfolk perceived her. He writes, “(they) had expected to behold her dimmed and obscured by a disastrous cloud, (but) were …show more content…

The garment is said to be, “fantastically embroidered and illuminat(ing)” (48) as well as spell-binding. Providing a picture of an immaculate letter ‘A’ its purpose becomes less clear or believable. The audience is not alone in needing a reminder of the connection between the sin and the lovely piece as the townspeople agree that no matter how pretty the symbol was, still Prynne would feel it “in her heart” (49), the encouragement following a proposal to replace it with a bland scrap of flannel. The significance of the scarlet letter is again eclipsed by its grand style in chapter fourteen, Hester and the Physician. While exploring the seashore, Hester’s daughter, Pearl takes it upon herself to craft her own letter ‘A’ to wear on her chest, since she was so impressed with her mother’s. The line between good and bad is very blurred in this case as Hawthorne forces the harmless symbol of a child to interact with and further, exist pleasantly within the limits/presence of this metaphoric brand. He taunts the reader in writing, “‘I wonder if mother will ask me what it means!’ thought Pearl” (162) pairing joyful curiosity with the dangerous ideas of lust and infidelity teetering over the edge of the clean-thought, creating anxiety as the reader watches the small drops of the horrible secret threaten to leak out

Get Access