preview

Scarlet Letter Transcendentalism

Decent Essays

The Scarlet Letter, a novel by Nathaniel Hawthorne may not seem to be the best novel in regards to Transcendentalist ideas. When compared to Walden, or Life in the Woods, by Henry David Thoreau, one should be able to see quite a few similarities in the way some of the characters in the story think and act. As with comparing any story to another, there will always be some differences that do seem to go against what the other story has to offer. While Walden, or Life in the Woods is primarily seen to be Transcendentalist work, The Scarlet Letter is more of a work that seems to defy many transcendental ideals, but somehow still seems to fit in some of the more popular ideas. Self-sufficiency is one of the main ideas of Transcendentalism. People …show more content…

In other transcendentalist works, forgiveness is something that appears quite often. The puritans however feel that sin is something that sticks with someone and can never be forgotten. Even the smallest accident could lead some people to feeling that an insanely harsh punishment is due. It seems as if the puritans in The Scarlet letter feel that adultery or even something smaller could be just as bad as murdering someone for fun. "The judgment of God is on me," answered the conscience-stricken priest. “It is too mighty for me to struggle with!”,"Heaven would show mercy," rejoined Hester, "hadst thou but the strength to take advantage of it." (Hawthorn 177). There are many problems associated with forgiveness of sin in the novel, and such a, that it can even be too hard for one to forgive oneself even if the sin was not really such a big deal. They feel that it is up to God to actually forgive them, not each other. In transcendentalism, forgiveness is much more common because it is not only about thinking for oneself, viewing the world with a new outlook on life, but also by accepting others and that everyone makes mistakes and sometimes people need to be given a second, third or fourth chance to make their lives and others’ better. In Walden, or Life in the Woods, a key theme is to value simplicity, and to accept what you cannot change. By adding in free thinking, a conclusion one can end up with is how people can change but it is up to them to work it out. All others can do is help others on their journey and forget about the past as it does not add anything to ones battle in daily

Get Access