Should Whitaker Punish Their Students For Plagiarism?

Plagiarism is a temptation every college student faces. It's also a serious issue that doesn't always get taken care of. I think the way it has been dealt with is strange. Strange in the sense that there isn't just one procedure when it comes to the punishment of those who plagiarize. In Raymond A. Schroth's article, he focused more so on the professor's side of the issue. He also presented ways to prevent the issue in effective ways and gave information on not so effective way. I really enjoyed his approach to the article. Trip Gabriel's article brought to light just how common the issue of plagiarism is. It made me truly question the way students are taught how not to plagiarize and if it needs to be revisited or updated so it's more geared

Plagiarism is a serious issue that may diminish the value of a scholarly work and interferes with the professional growth of an individual. For example, in 2003, Jayson Blair resigned from his position as a reporter for the New York Time because of “alleged plagiarism” (Dolak, 2003). Another case of plagiarism would be Matthew C. Whitaker, an associate professor at Arizona State University who in 2011 and 2015 was accused of plagiarism (Ryman, 2017). In both scenarios, Jayson Blair and Matthew C. Whitaker failed to properly paraphrase and cite sources (Dolak, 2003; Ryman 2017).

“Plagiarism will not be tolerated at any time; students are required to learn and be personally responsible for educating themselves about plagiarism and the appropriate forms of citation and referencing sources. “ By UoPeople’s statement of Academic Integrity, Professor Lovelit would not be following policy if she were to give Reggie a passing grade for work he knowingly

Evan Osnos writes about plagiarism and how it affects two parties or people. One being politicians, the other academic or college educator. Osnos gives an example of Montana Senator John Walsh, which was found that he’s paper that had been written were involve in some sort of plagiarism. Yet, Walsh was not punished severely, however, Osnos agues how are they not punished but professor or college students does.

In the written article, “Why Politicians Plagiarize So Often” by Evan Osnos it is very clear that plagiarism among individuals in the political world isn’t as uncommon as some may think. Throughout the article many well-known politicians were put in the hot seat and accused of plagiarism. One of these well-known individuals being Senator John Walsh. In the article it states that he was accused of plagiarism because, “…one of his graduate-school papers contained unattributed passages by other writers…” (Osnos, ¶.1). Although this remained a prevalent issue, he wasn’t the only one that was suspected or caught for plagiarism. Other individuals including Joe Biden, Rand Paul, Joseph McCarthy, and even Vladimir Putin. The issue of plagiarism has been a lingering subject for years, going as far back as the writing of the Declaration of Independence.

Professor Matthew C. Whitaker was first accused of plagiarism in 2011 by his colleagues. “They said that he lifted passages from other books, Wikipedia and a Washington post article and used them in material he published and in a 2010 speech about Arizona’s immigration law.” (Jaschik, 2015). A committee at ASU ruled against the faculty members saying that there was not blented plagiarism, only that he was careless in some cases. This

Almost all colleges enforce policy when students commit plagiarism. With regard to plagiarism, two authors’ arguments differ. One of authors, Emma Teitel, a student in Dalhousie University, argued that the punishment of plagiarism is un-fare. She was punished for plagiarism in her third year. She claimed that she just made a technical mistake on her essay and did not intentionally plagiarize from another author’s work (Teitel, November 8, 2011). On the other hand, according to Todd Pettigrew, a professor in Kings University, colleges should make a rule clearly for plagiarized assignments depending on the number of offenses. For example, for student who commits plagiarism the second time should get a stronger punishment than the first offense.

Plagiarism falls under academic ethics and Kaplan University policy on plagiarism is on par with most schools. Any violation of KU's plagiarism policy is categorized in three levels: “first offense of the Academic Integrity Policy: Failure of the assignment in which the action occurred, second offense of the Academic Integrity Policy: Failure of the class in which the action occurred and third offense of the Academic Integrity Policy: Expulsion or permanent dismissal from the University (Kaplan University, n.d., p. 3).” These consequences for violating Kaplan University plagiarism policy are clear and direct. When writing a paper four specific ways to avoid being charged with academic

Matthew Whitaker, a professor at ASU, has agreed to resign "after a series of plagiarism controversies dating back over four years." Mr Whitaker, observed by ASU faculty members, is reported using quotes from other sources for two books he wrote in which he got promoted for.

Kennedy once said, “A child miseducated is a child lost”. In this circumstance, President Kennedy’s statement is exceptionally true. By not receiving a severe punishment, these students are not receiving the valuable education of being held accountable for their actions. Not acknowledging the seriousness of plagiarism early on could eventually lead to much greater consequences than receiving a zero. In a point of fact, anyone who reproduces someone’s intellectual property can be prosecuted in a court of law. Understanding the severity of plagiarism early on could avoid such a punishment altogether, by accepting a punishment incomparable to the one that lays

The author of this article seems to be upset that the professor was only given a month of suspension for plagiarizing the paper. I do agree, with the author to be upset about the professor being suspended for a month. The reason I agree with the author because this man did not plagiarize the paper once, but he plagiarized the paper twice. If the professor was able to plagiarize from the same place twice, he could have plagiarized multiple times, and this was just the one time he was caught for plagiarizing. Also, the professor had went five years without admitting that he had plagiarized the paper. The school should feel guilty that one of their professors who they trust to teach future educators had plagiarized a paper that was published on

2. Students at UNC are penalized with an F in the course or suspension from the University for plagiarism. I feel that this is an extreme punishment, yet it will thoroughly persuade students from plagiarism. Students in college should have gained correct study habits and know how to cite things correctly. If this information was not introduced to them then they can use the universities

Everything starts with suspicion. A teacher, teaching assistant or professor discovers similarities thanks to a plagiarism report, and this is the beginning. After similarities are detected, evidence is passed to an academic integrity committee.

If there are going to be consequences for something, then they should apply them to everyone, not just some students. Some students do it, but not as bad as other students that completely use other’s work without changing any of the words. Christine Pelton did the right thing by following the policies, and by failing 28 of her students, but later in the article, it says prior to that year over 74% of the students have cheated or plagiarized something. Cheating can make a huge impact on your

I don't think there are ANY different consequences regarding plagiarism. Whether you’re in in college or have already graduated college. If you are caught plagiarizing you suffer the same consequences. You don’t receive your credits and you don't graduate or in Walsh’s situation you get your degree revoked. That’s it. Period. The end. He deserves it. As everyone says, “Fool me once shame on me” (The Army War College) “But fool me twice shame on you” (John