preview

Similarities Between Great Expectations And No Country For Old Men

Decent Essays

A simple Texan on the run and a poor child who grows into an ambitious and educated young man. No Country For Old Men, a novel by McCarthy, and Great Expectations, a novel by Charles Dickens, seem to have next to nothing in relation. However, upon closer inspection, the pair, while with greatly contrasting plots, tackle the same issue of morality, identity, and guilt. The protagonists of No Country For Old Men--Chigurh, the Sheriff-- have a slightly varied yet similar take on their morality. While Chigurh changes philosophy depending on the situation, the sheriff struggles with how morality should play in the world filled with violence and lawlessness when all he desires is justice. Charles Dickens also tackles the question of morality through his protagonist, Pip, who desires for self-improvement, and uses his moral conscience to justify himself and guide his future actions. In the beginning of No Country for Old Men, Chigurh engages in a conversation with a convenience store proprietor shortly after escaping a holding unit. Chigurh asks him to pick a side of a coin. When he asks on what terms, Chigurh replies, “How would that change anything?” After the clerk wins the coin toss, Chigurh tells him to keep it because it’s lucky, then he finishes with, “Anything can be an instrument. Small things. Things you wouldn’t even notice. They pass from hand to hand. People don’t pay attention. And then one day there’s an accounting. And after that nothing is the same”(McCarthy 57). Chigurh is a hardened criminal on the run. Morals mean very little to him. Having said that, he still possesses a warped system of dealing with different dilemmas. In the case of the impatient and suspicious proprietor, he refers to less menacing methods of intimidation than other encounters. Because the man has no idea who he is, or what he means, Chigurh first tests him by flipping the coin and then decides the man doesn’t deserve to die. He justifies his hunch by the concept that if the person is not a
McOsker 2 threat, then he can go quietly. Criminals don’t have the luxury to care about feelings. With the “lucky coin” in the baffled innocent’s hand, Chigurh imparts his twisted wisdom about the significance of

Get Access