preview

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's The Adventure Of The Speckled Band

Decent Essays

Sherlock Holmes is not guilty for the death of Dr.Grimsby Roylott. The title of this narrative is “The Adventure of the Speckled Band”, and was written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. There are 3 main justifications for the conclusion that Mr. Holmes is not guilty. He was acting in self-defense against the swamp adder. Sherlock could have no idea that Dr.Roylott was in the other room, in the exact spot in which the snake would reappear. Additionally, Sherlock had no idea of knowing that what he was defending himself from was a poisonous snake. These three statements support the conviction that Sherlock Holmes is not guilty. Sherlock Holmes had no way of knowing that the creature he was protecting himself from was a poisonous and deadly snake. …show more content…

He and Watson were in Julia’s room waiting for any kind of danger, and when Sherlock saw the snake he immediately tried to defend himself. If he had not, the snake would have most likely killed Watson and himself, just in the manner that it had killed Julia. Additionally, he and Watson were warned by Helen to be alert and ready to face any danger that may befall them throughout the night. This meant that they were prepared and ready to act, and consequently, when the snake appeared, Sherlock knew that it was the danger that Helen had warned them about. Even though he did not know what it was, he knew that it was what had killed Julia. Sherlock Holmes played a part in the death of Dr.Roylott, but he is not guilty for that death. He did not know it was a deadly snake that had attacked him. Additionally Sherlock could not have known that Dr.Roylott was waiting in the next room. Finally, he was acting in self-defense against a deadly animal. It could be argued that he is guilty because of the fact that he agitated the snake, but this claim can be offset by the fact that he was defending himself. Even though Sherlock Holmes played a part in Dr.Roylott’s death, he is not responsible for the doctor’s untimely

Get Access