preview

Society in the Worlds Created by George Orwell and Annie Proulx

Decent Essays

In the worlds created by George Orwell and Annie Proulx, society could be seen as the enemy. The society in Nineteen Eighty-Four is a dystopia; no civilians are permitted to have any amount of privacy and an act of adultery would be a crime against the leaders if the society: “The Party”. The time setting of Brokeback Mountain, in the 1960s, ensures that the characters sexuality makes them criminals. However Annie Proulx said: “this is not a story about gay cowboys but of destructive, rural homophobia.” Therefore, rather than being stories about ‘forbidden love’ as such, they are stories about the effect of repressive societies on relationships that are considered transgressive. By shunning transgressive relationships, society could be seen as the cause of death of Jack Twist and the death of Winston Smith’s personality. In both stories there is a definite underlining theme concerning forbidden relationships: secrecy and the fear of being found out. This is shown by the virtually perfectly parallel circumstances in which Julia and Winston, and Jack and Ennis have to meet. The idea of secrecy and fear, however, is best described in the last verse from “Two Loves” by Lord Alfred Douglas: Unmasked by night; I am true love, I fill The hearts of boy and girl with mutual flame.’ Then sighing, said the other, ‘Have thy will, I am the love that dare not speak its name.’ However, this poem relates more to the love shared in Brokeback Mountain because of the context of the

Get Access