“Students in “year-round” schools don't learn more than their peers in traditional nine-month schools”- Paul Von Hippel
Because we agree with the statement by Paul von Hippel, a sociologist at Ohio State university my partner and I reject the resolution: ¨Does year round schooling benefit students, their families & the community?¨
We offer the following two reasons to support our side. One, it has multiple effects on families with their children and it has an effect on maintenance/preparation within school on custodians.
Our first reason is: It has affects on families & students. There isn’t actual concrete proof that students actually benefit, Paul did his own study and said that an estimate of about 62% of all studies saying that “year round schooling benefits children” has been disproven. He constructed the study on hundreds of different students who attended year round school and also students who attended the normal year. a study done on an elementary school in Virginia showed that only 30-40% of the
…show more content…
Teachers and custodians were asked on their opinion about year round schooling and around 55% said that they would feel a sense of being worn out due to constant working without any long breaks. Teachers who don’t make enough money through teaching and wouldn’t be able to get a 2nd summer job. Iowa, is ranked 25th in the nation for teacher pay and on average teachers get paid less than 50k. To some teachers that isn’t enough to make payments and take care of a family. There are also logistical reasons to why year-round schooling wouldn’t be beneficial and one of the reasons are that not many schools provide air conditioning through the entire school. For example, here at MHS. The amount of money it would take to provide AC over a long period of time would be millions! It would more than likely take years to make up the money for that and also the AC’s would need to be replaced if one
Year-round schools have gained popularity among the United States, being a very communicated topic within middle class communities. These schools are generally argued about by whether they are beneficial or not. While there are many advantages to year-round schools, there are some disadvantages as well. A few of these disadvantages include the expenses of the schools, the schedules the schools provide, the involvement within the schools, and the actual effectiveness of these schools.
To begin with, year round schools cost to much. In the essay the author states that a high school in Arizona had a cost increase of 157,000 when they switched to year-round schooling! Now that is a lot of money going out the window. If you would just stick with how it's always been we would not have this problem. This way is so much better and cheaper for the students and the school.
Many people, including President Barack Obama believe that year round schooling is the best option for American students, because the year round system gives students equal amount of time in school, while increasing the efficiency of a single school building (Ave 1B). “More than two million students in some three thousand U.S. schools attend year round programs in 41 states” (Lawson 48). This astonishing number seems large, but really is only 2% of students in the United States. Many of the perceived advantages of year round schooling revolve around cost and learning efficiency, but in reality the traditional system gives essentially equal
Year round school affects a lot of people for many reasons. In the text it said that “most families plan vacations over the summer. Year-round schools restrict summer family vacations. They also don't allow students to go away to camp or take on summer jobs to earn money for the future.” This means that families usually will go on vacation in the summertime when it is warm out but year round schools are going to school at that time so they can’t go on a nice vacation. Also in the summer, kids sometimes do lemonade stands to earn money for their future but kids that go to year round schools can’t do that because they are stuck in school in the summer. Another piece of evidence from the text is that “too many breaks disrupt learning. The breaks
Mathew Lynch in Huff Post Education says “The Summer months are typically the highest ones for energy consumption. In fact, the average electricity bill for homeowners in the summer months goes up 4 to 8 percent, the same concept would be true of schools. Having empty classrooms in the summer months means less money going out to air conditioning and prevents other warm-weather costs from hitting school utility budgets.” Personally I couldn’t agree with that more. If the school board switches to the Year-Round schooling we will be wasting more money that this school doesn’t
Believe it or not keeping a school open costs quite a bit of money. If schools are open longer the maintenance costs go up about 10% more. Many people believe that having school year-round education may be cheaper but it certainly does not guarantee savings. These costs may add up and in turn interfere with budgets for other programs that are already struggling with funding such as sports, music, arts and other programs funded by the state. Also lets not forget air conditioning is not free. With today's current economy most students have to pay for their collage and in result get summer jobs or part-time jobs to raise money. Year-round schooling could make it difficult for students to keep jobs and save their money. Low income families can get hurt in this situation. Lastly, teachers must be paid for all the weeks they are working, with all these factors the cost of keeping schools open skyrockets. In Tempe, AZ, a high school experienced an increase of $157,000 per
This is one reason that we should not have year round school in the United States. Year round schools don't learn any more than the kids in traditional nine month school calendar. The article says,"Students in "year-round" schools don't learn more than their peers in traditional nine-month schools, new research has found." This shows that kids in year round school don't learn any more then kids in the nine month school calendar. If kids don't learn any more than their peers than they shouldn't have to go to year round school. Kids in school deserve to have a summer vacation to hang out with friends and family and to be able to travel.
Year-round schools affect multiple people because in the text it said, that teachers have more time to plan lessons to make them better, and so the students get more out of the lessons. This explains to you that teachers have more time to plan the lessons. And also it gives the students a break when they really need it, for example here is a quote that I got from the text, “One student said, "I love it. Just about the time I'm really tired, I get a break." This shows you a quote from the text about how relieving those breaks are. Another piece of evidence that the text said was that, teachers in schools with a long summer break (of 10 weeks) are so busy teaching the classes, that they have less time to plan lessons for their classes. This shows
Does year round school truly have a positive impact in the lives of students? Various studies do suggest that year round school is helpful. There are some disadvantages to this type of schooling that are preventing all schools from switching to this type of scheduling. In earlier times schools were only teaching throughout half of the year so that school would be out of session when it was time to work in the fields. This type of scheduling is still common today even though only a small portion of agriculture is tied into education and kids are no longer required to work. “In 1994, the National Education Commission on Time and Learning (1994) urged school districts to develop school calendars that acknowledged (a) differences in student learning and (b) the major changes taking place in American society. The report reflected growing concern about how the school calendar relates to students at risk for academic failure” (Cooper, Nye, Charlton, James, & Greathouse). As a result. many are fighting for year-round school. Year-round school has proven to be beneficial in the lives of students and has lead to greater success in the classroom. Although, there are some downfalls to year-round schooling.
Some advantages of year-round schooling include improved achievement, improved attendance by both teachers and students, reduced discipline problems, lower teacher stress, increased motivation due to frequent breaks, and increased opportunities for enrichment (Palmer and Bemis). During the two week breaks in between school sessions, students have the opportunity to take classes on karate, ballet, photography, cooking, and swimming. This intersession provides time for hands-on, big project classes that get kids involved in topics that interest them. Intersession can also be used as an intervention for students who are falling behind. “Karl Alexander, sociology professor at Johns Hopkins University, studied 800 students for more than 20 years in Baltimore’s elementary schools. He found that by ninth grade, low-income students had fallen 3 ½ grade levels behind their middle-class peers. And most of that gap was attributable to learning lost over the long traditional summer” (Schulte, 2009). The biggest driving force and proponent of year-round schooling is the effect of the “summer slide.” Students lose two months of achievement in math skills and students from low-income families lose more than two months in reading achievement according to the national Summer Learning
Have you ever thought about how year-round schooling can be beneficial to students? In today’s society, many school districts have been switching from a standard school year to year-round schooling. Year-round schools follow the basic 180 day school year, but the days are more spread out throughout the year following the 45-15 method. Forty five days of school, followed by fifteen day breaks. Year-round schooling is beneficial to many because it prevents students from gaining unwanted weight and causes less stress for teachers and students.
How would the population react if the schedule that structures many peoples’ entire year were to change? This change is a reality for a growing number of families across the country as a method of improving primary and secondary education through year-round school. Although many have come to accept or even embrace year-round school in an effort to help students retain more material, year-round school would actually disrupt the learning environment, be potentially detrimental for students and their family’s financial health, as well as that of the schools, and could take away from family and personal time.
There are many reasons why there should and shouldn’t be year round schooling. Like the benefits for elementary students. Also about the minority students and ESL. And middle and high school students need time to just be kids.
This are the good effect that come from year round school. The first one is that they no summer gap. So kids don't forget every
“It’s for the public it’s year round and it 's also for the schools because we 're going to re-establish our school programs and all our outreach programs” Susan Hayward. Will year round schooling help or benefit the schools of the United States and society? Year round schools could change the reasons why teachers are teaching ("Top 10 Reasons"). Elimination of extended breaks from schools in the United States. would be beneficial to the population.