preview

Teaching For Too Long English As A Second Language

Better Essays

For too long English as a second language has been seen as a separate pull-out class at the elementary level or a separate subject in secondary schools. What would an English Second Language (ESL) co teaching model look like in a general education classroom and what is the impact on ELL student achievement?
Priority one is to establish the meaning of co-teaching and then establish what it is not. According to Honingsfeld & Dove (2008) co teaching was a traditional collaboration between the general education teacher and the special education teacher. Susan Cushman (2004) describes co teaching as a shared responsibility for teaching students in an assigned classroom. “It is a fun way for students to learn from two people who may have …show more content…

p.2).
Co teaching is not having the ESL teacher working with a small group of ELLs apart from general class. Unless the model is being use for specialized instruction it carries with it the danger of putting ELLs in a minority (Pappamihiel 2012). It is not one teacher teaching followed by another teacher teaching. It is not one teacher teaching while the other teacher is making copies and it is not providing an assignment in which one teacher acts as a tutor while the other teacher’s ideas prevail (Cushman, 2004).
In 1974 the Supreme Court case Lau v. Nichols ruled that schools are obligated to provide English instruction, access to the curriculum, and materials to students who do not speak English. But it did not suggest how schools needed to meet that obligation. Schools still had significant latitude in deciding on the model of ESL services. Since English Learning Learners (ELLs) needed to learn grade-level content material while they are acquiring English, ESL instructors began pulling students from mainstream classrooms as a way to accommodate their instruction. Several problems however occur when pulling ELLs from the classroom. First, most ESL pull out programs are taught with a separate ESL curriculum that is not related to the content in the mainstream classroom (Young, 2006). The general education teacher and the ESL teacher do not get to or have time to collaborate and coordinate their lessons. Second, ELLs miss the content lessons

Get Access