preview

Testamentary Capacity To Make Will Case Study

Decent Essays

Capacity to make will. The court held that there was sufficient mental capacity – the mind need not be in perfect shape and the disposition logical in order to have testamentary capacity. The excerpt below summarizes the court’s ruling in favor of admitting the will to probate:

The jury in this case also heard testimony about Pat's health problems, including testimony about a 1983 electric shock accident, his headaches, and his declining health in 2005. Brenda conceded that Pat performed his daily work after the accident; he worked cattle on horseback. Members of Pat's family testified that Pat possessed all his mental faculties after the accident, noticing no change in his daily behavior beyond some difficulty walking. The jury heard testimony that, in December 2004, Pat suffered from headaches …show more content…

She claims that, because no evidence demonstrates that Pat discussed his children or the approximate nature of his property with the witnesses on the date he executed his will, Pat lacked the capacity to make a judgment about bequeathing his property. She asserts that Pat did not know who his children were because his will names a child whom he never adopted in a legal proceeding, and it omits an alleged sixth child. But a finding of testamentary capacity does not hinge entirely on direct evidence that the testator discussed the details of his children, wealth, or disposition at the time he signed his will. See Prather, 76 Tex. at 584-85, 13 S.W. at 545-46. The jury heard direct evidence of Pat's general mental condition on the day he executed his will and the attending months before and after: this evidence supports its determination that Pat knew that he was executing his will and that he had deliberately chosen Patricia to be his sole beneficiary. The evidence at trial “would enable reasonable and fair-minded people to reach the verdict under review.” See City of Keller, 168 S.W.3d at

Get Access