preview

The Boys Are Not All Right By Michael Ian Black

Decent Essays

White, male, New York Times writer, Michael Ian Black in his article, “The Boys Are Not All Right” (Feb. 21 2018), claims that toxic masculinity and the lack of meninism to change old stereotypes of masculinity causes men to commit mass shootings. He supports his claim by first states that women are “redefining” what it means to be a woman while men have not, then by saying that there has not been a movement to help men “toward a full expression of their gender”, next by stating that men are “trapped “in “outdated… masculinity”, and finally by stating that men only have two options to “preserve” his masculinity: “withdrawal or rage”. Black’s purpose is to illuminate another causation of mass shooting that is being ignored in order to show a …show more content…

He claims that men need a movement such as the feminist movement to allow “full expression of their gender” and to change the “outdated model of masculinity.” To begin with, Black uses a joke that he claims emasculates men when it should not: all you have to do is order for a man. This humorous anecdote introduces to the audience the idea that modern masculinity has become an issue when it shouldn’t be. Furthermore, Black uses hypophora by asking what these shootings have in common, and then immediately answering it. First, he says that these shootings to have guns in common, but continues by saying that these shootings also have boys in common, saying that “girls aren’t pulling the triggers.” This tells the audience exactly what the author thinks about the subject and is basically the thesis of the article. Moreover, it connects the idea of masculinity with school shootings, setting up the main idea of the …show more content…

The language needed to change this paradigm is seen as “sensitive and feminine” and using this language risks being “emasculated”. Black portrays men sympathetically, showing that he is not aggressive towards men, but rather understands the cause of the problem, and recognizes that it is not necessarily the fault of men. Instead, this “toxic masculinity” is the fault of old stereotypes and masculinity being “strength”and “aggression and competitiveness.” Consequently, Black also uses figurative language to describe his son “swallowing his frustration, burying his worry.”
. Moreover, Black uses first-hand evidence to support his claim that this definition of masculinity is harmful, stating that when he posted his ideas of masculinity and shootings on twitter, he received “hateful replies” and was called “soy boy” (linking consumption of soy to estrogen). These replies questioned Black's “manhood,” proving his

Get Access