The Chilling Torture at Abu Ghraib Prison Essay

and psychological consequences of torture in regards to Iraqi detainees due to months of abuse and mistreatment. The lack of sound medical professionals also needs to be called to attention. Upon the interviewing and debriefing the detainee victims in this case, resulted in significant long term physical and psychological suffering. Forensic psychological evaluations tests such as the Istanbul protocol were conducted on both former Iraqi detainees of Abu Ghraib. (Keller, 2006) The use of this test…

took the infamous Abu Ghraib photographs was “…convicted by a court-martial, in May of 2005, of conspiracy to maltreat prisoners, dereliction of duty, and maltreatment, and sentenced to six months in prison, a reduction in rank, and a bad-conduct discharge (Gourevitch).” So the debate of whether or not Abu Ghraib was torture seems moot. From there, it would seem absurd to argue in support of it anywhere, in any country, for any reason. It is undeniable that what went on at Abu Ghraib was never a series…

robbed of their human rights and cast in the role of criminals solely because of their culture and the acts of groups they likely did not know. In the calm aftermath and a chance to reflect on this behaviour some American officials admitted that Abu Ghraib was the functional equivalent of the 9/11 attack, only committed this time by the United States (Greenberg 2005: 98). Prior to 9/11there had been various terrorist attacks on Americans around the world and on American soil. However the events…

self" (Franzoi, 2003, Pg 217). Once again, fear could have been an issue in the persuasion of the guards. The guards realized that they had to do their jobs and act in compliance with orders or face the consequences. In many of the torture pictures at Abu Ghraib, the prisoners are wearing bags on their heads or something to mask their face. The supervisors of the jail could have masked the inmates to make the guards feel less responsible about the vicious acts. Since the victim was masked and…

Allegedly, the outsourcing of terror suspects to countries such as Jordan, Egypt, Morocco and Syria, countries that engage in torture, also occurred. In addition, the International Committee of the Red Cross reported on methods of physical and psychological coercion used to extract information from prisoners in Iraq. These methods include beatings with hard objects, slapping, punching, kicking, prolonged exposure to the sun, and parading detainees naked, sometimes with women’s underwear on their…

The responsibility of this failure is institutional as well as personal at higher levels. Abu Ghraib and the Root Causes of Abuse When President Bush declared the War on Terror after the incident of September 11, 2001, he was declaring a new kind of war on a different kind of enemy. The al-Qaeda terrorist group who were responsible for the destruction of World Trade Center is organized differently than any enemy that the U.S. has faced before. Since the terrorists were determined to target large…

Another problem with the use of torture is that in some cases, as in Abu Ghraib, it is done for the sheer entertainment of bored guards and not necessarily to accomplish any goal. What it all boils down to is that torture to extract intelligence from enemy combatants, whether it provides information beneficial to our national security or not, should not be used under any circumstances. First, let’s address this issue from a purely moral standpoint. Torture is wrong. There is no denying that fact…

voiceless', brought him to the attention of the FBI and the local Philadelphia Police. At one point the FBI tried to frame him for a murder. It was only his work record that enabled him to walk free. The FBI began amassing a 600-page file on Mumia Abu-Jamal when he was a 15-year-old high school activist. The FBI added his name to the National Security Index and the ADEX index of those persons to be rounded up and interned in a national emergency. (West 24) It was whilst out driving his cab…

Torture is one of the most extreme methods of eliciting information; unfortunately, it has been used for centuries and is still prevalent worldwide. Thesis: Counterterrorism through interrogation is wrong and leads to false information. Scientific Perspective In 2006 the Intelligence Science Board, a civilian board that advises the U.S. Department of Defense on technical and scientific matters, stated that there was information to support the declaration that torture produces reliable information…

This cannot be maintained in all cases, as such with rape and torture. These crimes must be addressed with something which the punishment, even if it does not fit the crime exactly, matches it in respect to severity (Kant 145). Kant holds the belief that “whoever has committed murder, must die... [for] there is no likeness or proportion between life, however painful, and death” (Kant 145). Saying this, Kant also acknowledges that “[the criminal’s] death, however, must be kept free from all maltreatment…