preview

The Criticism Of George Henry Hastings Sibley

Decent Essays

Was the criticism of Gov./Col. Sibley justified? Describe what his explanations were and the arguments of those who wanted him to hurry up. Draw a conclusion evaluating which arguments were best.

Governor Henry Hastings Sibley is a memorable figure in Minnesota history, but one that is laced with controversy and suspicion. These controversies extend from his early career in fur trading to his leadership of Minnesota’s militia in the Great Sioux Uprising of 1862. The criticism of Governor Sibley was mainly because of his hesitation to engage with the Indians and his constant complaints to territorial governor Alexander Ramsey about lack of men and supplies, but is simply not justified when the full scope of his problems are understood. …show more content…

A lack of horses meant that Sibley could not reconnoiter the wilderness between St. Peter and Ft. Ridgeley, which left his army much more vulnerable to surprise attack. Also, Sibley was placed in charge of the refugees who had escaped to St. Peters and were now looking for shelter and food. Sibley also feared the much larger Indian population that his army had to face. “Sibley intended to be a thorough and careful commander. His troops would move against the Indians only when they were fully prepared” (122). This slowed Sibley down because he refused to take a steamboat to Shakopee until he had the supplies he felt necessary to take on the Indians. At Ft. Ridgely, anger and fear festered after the first attack on the fort as to when reinforcements would come. This also held true for the town of New Ulm which was scrambling to defend itself under the leadership of Colonel Flandrau. While these towns were being attacked, Sibley had gathered an army of 1,340 troops, but still complained about the lack of supplies and training his men had. As the book aptly put it, however, “…neither were the defenders of New Ulm and Fort Ridgley, and they fought with determination, improvised when necessary, and made do without what they could not get and still they bested superior numbers of Indians” (177-178). Sibley’s delays in advancing his troops and attacking the Indians caused heavy responses from the people of Minnesota. Many called for

Get Access