preview

The Flying Dutchm Drama Over The Emotional Transparency

Decent Essays

The Flying Dutchman seemed to favor epic drama over the emotional transparency, which is rather ironic considering its central theme of love as redemption. The music certainly didn’t lack in excitement, though, and it seemed almost reminiscent of a film score with its grand, sweeping themes. I think the distinct characteristic of The Flying Dutchman was its recurring use of certain motifs to describe or refer to characters. The Dutchman’s theme, with its majestic french horn melody, featured in the score not only when the Dutchman appeared in a scene, but also when other characters mentioned him. Other recurring motifs were the gentle theme comprised of mainly woodwinds and strings—associated with Senta’s love—the violent, dramatic motif …show more content…

I don’t think the vocals ever overshadowed the orchestral music, which is not the case in most operas. Puccini’s Turandot had a markedly different sound from the other two operas. The obvious difference is that Puccini used pentatonic scales in his composition—as opposed to the Western occidental scales—in an effort to emulate traditional Chinese music. Interestingly, the composition didn’t feature any actual Chinese instruments aside from the gong. Puccini seemed to use a lot of percussion in general, and instruments such as the xylophone and bells featured often. I don’t actually think Turandot fits within the idea of Verismo opera, as I always thought Verismo was supposed to represent a return to ‘real’ life and the stories of common people. The opera seemed to reflect the sort of ideals found in Romantic music, especially Puccini’s attempt to evoke a far-off, fairy tale-like locale with his exotic music.
Of the three operas, Turandot had the most memorable arias, which also seemed like they worked the best as standalone songs. No part of The Flying Dutchman could have been taken out and been considered its own separate ‘song,’ but I do think bits of Turandot could exist as such. If not Romantic in terms of the musical style, I still think Turandot’s music was the most “romantic” of the three performances in terms of its emotional qualities. Putting aside the

Get Access