preview

The Giver Moral Disobedience

Decent Essays

“Moral Disobedience” The Giver, a dystopian futuristic novel written by young adult author Lois Lowry won the 1994 Newbery Medal, and sold more than 12 million copies since its publication, according to USA Today, (McClurg). This literary masterpiece presents the reader with an unusual society that has eliminated pain, fear, war, emotion, and diversity. But as Jonas discovers the previous world, and uncovers many shocking secrets of his society, he finds himself living in an environment filled with vile practices that he can no longer tolerate. Jonas emphasizes the importance of reacting to unlawful orders or inhumane practices. "If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so,” (Thomas Jefferson). We should …show more content…

WW2 took the lives of more than 72.4 million people, ("11 Facts About the Holocaust.") and killed more than two-thirds of all the people living in Europe at the time, ("World War 2 Statistics."). As part of their service to their country, the Nazis were commanded to perform horrific actions any reasonable person would question. These tortures included, “putting people’s hands in boiling water until the skin and fingernails came off...pulling teeth and cutting and twisting off the ears; running electric current through the victims…” ("Nazi Torture and Medical Experimentation.") “Prisoners were submerged in ice water to see the effects of hypothermia, injected with chemicals and poisons to test their effectiveness, sterilized, vivisected, and operated on without anesthetic,” (Smallwood). When many of these prominent Nazi soldiers were put on trial in Nuremberg, Germany, they argued they were serving their country, following orders from their superior. Here, we confront the thought-provoking question of whether it is just to obey your superior or serve your nation while breaking the moral code of humanity. These Nazis committed acts and imposed punishments upon their prisoners, that many have labeled as sinister, inhumane, unjust, and gruesome. But can we blame them for following the demands of their superiors and their country? Is it

Get Access