preview

The Heterogeneity Of Art Cinema, By Geoffrey Bordwell

Good Essays

Charles Pierse 11510667

In answering the claim that “the heterogeneity of art cinema makes a mockery of the attempts that have been made to treat it as a distinct genre”, I felt it important to choose readings that I felt tried to deal with the elements of art cinema in a wider sense as opposed to focusing solely on a particular film/director or country. With this in mind the readings I found most apt for this task were, “Art Cinema” by Geoffrey Nowell-Smith whose essay the topic arose from, “The Art Cinema as Mode of Film Practice” by David Bordwell, “The French New Wave” by T Jefferson Kline and finally “The European Art Movie” by Thomas Elsaesser. The films I have decided to apply these readings to are “Vivre sa Vie” (Godard, 1962) …show more content…

The essay begins and ends by discussing Ingmar Bergman specifically, which while interesting and at times relevant, is for the most part superfluous in directly dealing with the topic at hand. The mid section of the essay I believe however is acutely pertinent. Elsaesser moves from his original specific focus on Bergman and extends it to European and thus art cinema. He raises the issue of the perceived notion of American (classical) cinema versus European (deviant) cinema. In addressing this issue Elsaesser breaks down the commonalities within each respective cinema. It is in this breakdown that I found this essay not only helpful but also intriguing in it’s novel approach to the topic. He provides the crudest definition of the supposed opposing cinemas as “Quick Hollywood and Slow Europe”. In his expansion of the “slow” nature of European cinema he shows his attentiveness to the components of art cinema. Citing slow delivery of dialogue, less cuts and deep staging as trademarks of art cinema as a whole. He then goes even further than these technical aspects and delves into the shared “self conscious” plot structures, as well as the distinct lack of strong causality in these films. He suggests that art cinema merely sets a different task to viewers than classical, be it discovering a character’s true motivation, piecing together a “scattered timeline” or a having to separate the “real” from the “imagined”. It’s worth noting that “Wild Strawberries” is a film that presents the audience with every one of these tasks. I believe that this essay would not be only useful in answering against the proposed topic but also provides a fresh view on the elements which art cinema is composed

Get Access