preview

The Importance Of Fairness In Sports

Satisfactory Essays

Whether one knows of an athlete who has doped, performance enhancing drugs has long been a debated public controversial concern. The dilemma as to whether or not allowing athletes to dope make it fair for those who dope to those who do not. On the one hand, there are those who are concerned that the lift on the ban would ruin the spirit of sport, whereas others who believe that lifting the ban would make sports more competitive. Thomas H. Murray, former president of The Hastings Center (1999-2012) and former director of the Center for Biomedical Ethics in the School of Medicine at Case Western Reserve University, he argues in “Making Sense of Fairness in Sports,” published by Hastings Center Report, that the ban on performance enhancing drugs should be maintained. In this paper, I will argue that Murray’s argument is strong and cogent. I will first explain Murray’s argument. Next I will evaluate the argument and articulate its weaknesses. Finally, I will offer some suggestions as to how the argument could be improved.
In Murray’s article, he focuses on the bio-ethical principle of justice. Fairness in sports is to play in accordance to natural law as in our given human physical limitations. Whereas, to not be fair in sports is to using synthetic drugs that will provide the athlete with an unfair advantage over other athletes who do not. Thomas H. Murray’s argument is inductive and appeals predominately on consequentialism in order to induce the audience of possible

Get Access