preview

The Importance Of Fairy Tales

Decent Essays

Despite the similarities of both scholars about children’s autonomy, there are few differences that sets them apart. Haase claims, “After all, teachers…exert a certain control over the popular reception of fairy tales by determining to a great extent not only the nature of the tales that are made accessible to children, but also the context of their reception” (445). Haase believes that teachers are the problem why children are having a hard time claiming their power over fairy tales. Apparently, teachers hold the power over what children can observe in fairy tales. The perception of teachers who read the fairy tales to children can maneuver through the story to make children believe in what they believe in. Haase also states “It is no …show more content…

This difference on their perspective upon how educators can contribute to children’s self-governance imposes that it is not only through fairy tales that children can attain autonomy. The story “the Juniper Tree” did not mention any educators that influenced the boy to attain sovereignty. The boy, rather, had to teach himself about the things that killed him to avenge his killer. This pose questions to both scholars’ claims about the power that educators have on children’s autonomy. It shows that self-government is not merely taken from fairy tales that teachers provide children, but it can also be taken through self-induced learning. Moreover, both scholars differ on the platforms that they use to help them make their point. Haase talks on the ownership of fairy tales through historical and theoretical analysis. He proposes facts from the past, such as his graduate student back in 1990 and how back in the day, individuals thought of classic fairy tales to “hold a revered if not sacred place in the modern Western culture” (435). He also discussed the Germans’ association with classic fairy tales and how this affected their nation’s literacy education in the 1800s. On the other hand, Sipe focused more on the practical part of how to encourage independence over fairy tales for children. In his essay, Sipe had a dedicated

Get Access