preview

The Legal Rules Of Equity

Better Essays

Introduction.
Equity by its nature is a fluid subject where maxims are simply guidelines to be used or ignored at the whim of the court and solutions to litigation sometimes aim at justice (or expedience) at the expense of the legal rules of equity (equity will [sometimes] follow the law).
This is illustrated by the two overarching maxims where equity will not assist a volunteer and equity will not perfect an imperfect gift when in practise there are established systems of equity which often do assist a volunteer and under the very flexible principle of benevolent construction the courts often do perfect an imperfect gift. This is the case even where it appears to directly contradict common law such as that from Bridge LJ in Paul v Constance .
Into this fluid area of the law is imposed the common law in the premise of this essay from Turner LJ in Milroy v Lord : There are three modes of making a gift and these modes are mutually exclusive (1) An outright transfer of the legal title to the property (2) A transfer of the legal title to the property to a trustee to hold or (3) A self-declaration of trust.
This essay will look towards the cases and academic comment discussing this premise and the further recognised areas where equity does assist a volunteer and will perfect an imperfect gift and will conclude that it is difficult to state with any certainty that anything is mutually exclusive in equity and trusts.
Discussion.
The overview of this discussion is that there does

Get Access