preview

The Origin of Modern Humans

Best Essays

Throughout history, humans have asked many questions in regards to our own beginnings. Religion and science have examined what makes us who we are, and have tried to answer the enduring question of our own modern origins. Scientifically, theories are still debated as to when, where, and how modern Homo sapiens came to be what they are today. There are two major theories that now dominate the discussions of experts in the field of biological anthropology: the “Out-of-Africa” model and the “Multiregional” model of evolution. Stringer and Andrews argue that genetic and paleontological evidence supports a more recent Out-of-Africa model as opposed to a more drawn out Multiregional method that also incorporates gene flow (1263). In contrast, …show more content…

Stringer and Andrews published an article in 1988 entitled “Genetic and Fossil Evidence for the Origin of Modern Humans.” In this article, they claim that the multiregional method is based on the idea that Homo erectus arose in Africa then traveled throughout the world (1263). It wasn’t until later that modern humans arose through “a series of evolutionary grades” (1263). This, Stringer and Andrews say is false. Using modern genetic data, Stringer and Andrews argue that the structure of the multiregional model is right in that it says distance allows for distinct derived traits to arise in separated populations, but these populations weren’t spread through Eurasia. Instead, these populations first were geographically isolated in Africa allowing for unique character traits to develop there. Rather than Homo erectus arising and then moving, Homo sapiens did this on their own. Genetic data used by Stringer and Andrews was collected by comparing mtDNA (mitochondrian DNA) between various populations (1264). The African populations had larger variation in their mtDNA, so this showed that the mtDNA split much earlier for Africans than for other populations in Asia, Australia, New Guinea, and Europe (1264). Other genetic evidence counteracts this proposal though. Genetic distances calculated from blood groups, for example, suggest that there is a closer bond between caucasoids (European groups) and negroids (African

Get Access