preview

The Proposal : Keystone Xl Pipeline Approval Act

Good Essays

In this paper I will write in opposition to the: S.1-Keystone XL Pipeline Approval Act. If enacted, this bill would allow the TransCanada corporation to build and manage an oil pipeline across North America. Authorization of the bill will require amendments to energy conservation policy, as well as, established building codes. Essentially, these changes liberate a building owner’s ability to manage energy manage energy consumption, and requires the Department of Energy to actively monitor this consumption. In terms of cost, Government funds will be moved from current energy programs then put towards pipeline instillation. This aid will not be a direct stipend, rather states and local organizations will be incentivized by the government to …show more content…

On the contrary, I argue that economic growth is important, but the destructive environmental effects this bill will bring about outweigh their benefit. The extraction of the oil sands will cause immediate damage to the ecosystem, and the Transportation of these sands could pollute the drinking water of over 2.3 million Americans (Denneky). For the remainder of this paper I will elaborate on my arguments against the bill, and address the arguments in favor of the bill. Arguments against The damage caused by extraction of these oil sands is not a theoretical problem. Over the past sixteen years more than two million acres of the Canadian boreal forest has been cleared to extract these sands (Nikiforuk). Not only does the extraction process cut down trees it also produces more greenhouse gasses than the extraction of crude oil, and leaves polluted residue across the extraction sight. These contaminants then spread to surrounding bodies of water. Once these contaminants have reached these water supplies they have an immediate effect on wildlife. Fish have been found with cancerous growths in rivers near extraction sites (Forrest). From this we should infer that not only has this oil mining had a negative on wildlife, but it could also pose health risks to local residents near the extraction sites. Though there is little Americans can do to prevent Canada’s current extraction. By not installing the

Get Access