preview

The Reality Effect By Roland Barthes

Decent Essays

A Significant Insignificance
At what values should a seemingly pointless description or detail be taken at? When writers so often put so much labor into their works, it is a naive assumption to think a detail is just a part of moving the novel along. Roland Barthes, an esteemed literary critic, elaborates on this conclusion in his essay “The Reality Effect”, arguing the most superfluous details have a significant impact on the analysis of a piece of literature and that these small details are essential to a modern work of literature .The seemingly insignificant details could be overlooked, however, it is what makes the setting and actions within a work of literature appear to be reality. Among several works of literature, this proves …show more content…

These so called “superfluous” details can appear anywhere in a novel and are sometimes so mundane that it seems nearly unnoticeable at first. For example, in Ernest Hemingway's The Sun Also Rises he clearly shows the repetition of Lady Brett Ashley mentioning she is going to bathe.In a society where it is considered abnormal not to bathe, why would Hemmingway continually have had Brett mention she is going to bathe if it was not an important, though small, detail the audience needed to know to have a deeper understanding of her character. Brett’s mention of bathing so frequently is symbolic of her desire to purify herself from her unorthodox sexual actions. This shows a deep-rooted insecurity in Brett that otherwise would not be seen as clearly. She is seen as a sexual character throughout the novel, and it is understood that she is unhappy in her life, but her guilt with being such a sexual person would not be otherwise distinguished if she did not show her yearning to cleanse herself. It is also this inner conflict that is seen that makes Brett appear to be a more complex and realistic character because she struggles with the actions she wants, and has chosen, and what is deemed acceptable in society. In other cases, a detail might stand out as slightly unusual, but not immediately have its implications seen clearly. In Tuesdays with

Get Access