preview

The Relationship Between Brown And Faith In Young Goodman Brown

Decent Essays

In “Young Goodman Brown”, Nathaniel Hawthorne depicts the negative effects of lying with Brown and his relationship with his wife, Faith. The relationship between Brown and Faith seems loving, as the story begins with Faith blessing him and Brown worrying about her before departing on his meeting with the devil. However, their dishonesty to each other leads to a conclusive end to their loving relationship when Brown comes back from his journey. Another broken relationship is in “The Insufficiency of Honesty”, in which Stephen Carter presents an example about an unfaithful man confessing to his wife that he has cheated on her for the past thirty-five years. The two examples are relationships that shatters, in which Brown stops loving Faith, …show more content…

Judith Viorst’s “The Truth about Lying” briefly introduces the topic of Protective lies, in which one lies to protect the other party from the truth; however, it is very presumptuous to assume we always know what’s “good” for the person. Even if, going by the previous example, one knows telling the truth about the money and being forced to buy alcohol for the father is going to have a bad effect on the father, we never know the intentions behind the drinking of the father, or whether the father is saving up secretly for the daughter. There are so many ‘what-ifs’ that we cannot presumably present lying as fully justifiable. Thus, even if lying may be with good intentions, I claim that Miriam’s statement is true because lying destroys the trust in both sides of the relationship, avoids instead of resolves conflicts, and maintains boundaries. First, I will elaborate on the lies Faith and Brown had for each other, which builds up deception and their lack of faith in their relationship. When Brown is leaving Faith to meet with the Devil, Faith pleads but finally relents and states, “Then God bless you...and may you find all well when you come back” (Hawthorne, 387). Her gesture is sincere because she wishes him good luck and hopes that no harm comes his way. She even trusts Brown enough to go on a journey he did not further detail. However, Faith is contradicting with both words and appearance. Her strange word choice of

Get Access