preview

The Rules For Construction Of Guarantees And Indemnities

Better Essays

The rules for construction of guarantees and indemnities have recently changed course creating significant judicial confusion and debate over the correct approach. The High Court decision in Andar Transport Pty Ltd v Brambles Ltd (‘Andar’) has reinstated the views in Ankar Pty Ltd v National Westminster Finance (Aust) Ltd ( 'Ankar '), that the liability of a surety is strictissimi juris and that ambiguous contractual provisions should be construed in favour of the surety. However, Andar’s application of guarantee construction principles to the interpretation of indemnities have created confusion and debate about the position of from the courts earlier commercial construction favoured in Darlington Futures Ltd v Delco Aust Pty Ltd …show more content…

First, a guarantee is “a collateral contract to answer for the debt, default or miscarriage of another who is or is contemplated to become liable to the person to whom the guarantee is given”. The surety or guarantor gives a guarantee to the creditor or guarantee to ensure the performance of obligations of a principal debtor, and can extend to “existing or future legal obligations arising from contract, bailment, tort or an unsatisfied judgment”. Second, an indemnity is “a promise to protect another against loss from an event or events, or set of circumstances” and is “elastic and may be used more generally to describe any arrangement under which a party is not to suffer loss”. The promisor will therefore indemnify the other party from any loss occasioned from the circumstance. However, despite similar objectives, the two methods of surety do undertake a different promise and assume a different nature of liability, and this distinction of obligation is accordingly a matter of construction.

The different liability of guarantees and indemnities ensure that the different instruments are commonly used together to cover all bases, or separately according the outcome of risk allocation. Typically, the nature of a guarantee is to secure the performance of a principal debtor, however

Get Access