Individually, or Collective?
(Who is to Blame in the Play Macbeth by William Shakespeare)
In a lot of stories there is always the main antagonist. Often throughout the stories the antagonist creates many problems in the story on his or her own doing. Everything that they do, they do on their own and there is nothing that influences them to do these things. Sometimes it is quite the opposite, there is perhaps something that greatly influences this person to do the bad things. In the play Macbeth by William Shakespeare there is a lot of trying to figure out who is to blame for all of the bad things happening in the play. Macbeth is obviously everyone’s go to guy to blame because he is the one that is committing the act of violence or the one commanding the assault. He is definitely the antagonist of the story because of the things that he does, but is he really the only one to be blamed for these things? I think that in the play Macbeth there are a few people that you could blame: Macbeth, the witches, and Lady Macbeth. The first person that is definitely to blame for all of these actions is Macbeth himself. No matter what the circumstances are he was the one that was the final say in everything that he did. You could definitely argue that at the beginning it wasn’t his fault, which I agree with, but no matter what he was still making the final calls in all of this. By the end of the story Macbeth has become a completely different man with everything that he does. No
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysGet Access
In William Shakespeares Macbeth, psychosis, hallucinations and pride are a major characteristic shown in each character. The main characters that show these characteristics were Macbeth and Lady Macbeth, particularly with the murder of King Duncan. The question being, who is more responsible Lady Macbeth or Macbeth? There are reasons to believe both sides, but it is more believable that Lady Macbeth was the prime cause because she pressured Macbeth to commit the act of regicide just so he could be higher in power because he was runner up.
In the Shakespeare play, Macbeth, Macbeth is responsible for all the deaths in the play because Macbeth didn’t have to do anything about the prophecies, he could have chosen not to kill King Duncan, and Macbeth decided all on his own to have Macduff’s family killed.
Macbeth, despite influences of the witches and Lady Macbeth, is responsible for his downfall. The witches are not fully to blame but do play a part in Macbeth's tragedy. In William Shakespeare’s play "Macbeth", Macbeth is a hero who soon destroys himself by his own wicked and selfish ambitions. To a certain degree, the witches can be blamed for the tragedy, although the blame can easily fall amongst Macbeth’s ambitious nature, and Lady Macbeth’s manipulation. Overall, the witches play an important role in the tragedy, but the blame cannot be purely placed on the witches as there are the other factors involved in the play, causing the tragic ending.
Throughout many works of literature, it can be difficult to determine the victim and the aggressor, with many different pieces of text interpreted in a variety of ways. This is common in tragedies, especially, where the downfall of a character occurs. In the play, Macbeth, the main character, Macbeth, effectively reaches a downfall after important interactions with some of the other characters. He had changed as a person from the influence of what other characters had led him to believe. Macbeth arguably lost control of his mind, and he couldn’t bring himself to think rationally after the murder of Duncan, therefore the play works in favor of pitying Macbeth rather than blaming him.
“When Lady MacBeth receives the letter from MacBeth telling her that he wants to kill Duncan, she fears that he would not have the courage to go through with it” (Shakespeare 31). She brings out the worst in him and encourages him to kill King Duncan. She persuades him by constantly telling him negative things to get MacBeth to believe that he is doing the right thing. “Look like th’ innocent flower, but be the serpent under ’t” (Shakespeare 35). Lady MacBeth is the one who tells MacBeth to be this vicious creature and makes him think that killing King Duncan is okay. Because of Lady Macbeth’s behavior, MacBeth was led to become a murderer. Macbeth should not be held accountable for his actions since Lady MacBeth is the one who convinced him to commit the crime that started his madness and turn him into a monster.
Macbeth Essay In the famous play “The Tragedy of Macbeth” by William Shakespeare, the main character is convinced by witches to become king of scotland by murdering the king. The question is whether it is Macbeth to blame for his actions or the witches. it becomes clear the witches caused the events of the play when you examine the power of suggestion the witches had over Macbeth, the beliefs about witches at the time, and Macbeth’s personal responsibility.
Anytime something happens in the world, humanity always attempts to put the blame on just one person, but often there are other factors to consider. Even when an event might have started out as innocent, with the influence of other characters, that same moment in time can become corrupted. Which leads to the question of who ultimately has responsibility and is to blame for the murders and events throughout Macbeth? Macbeth, a Scottish general, receives a prophecy from three Weird Sisters that eventually he will be the King of Scotland. Shortly after, ambition dominates him and he is encouraged to action by his wife, so he murders King Duncan and takes the throne. Although in Macbeth the Weird Sisters and Lady Macbeth both exert some control over the events, Macbeth has the ultimate responsibility over the murders.
The human mind is very complicated, actions are hardly ever the result of someone's own free will. Often, outside influences will force an action out of someone that they very well may believe was figmented from their own free will, and this can create the misconception that someone is completely to blame for their actions. In Macbeth, one can see the truth behind this statement. When someone asks, who is to blame for the downfall of Macbeth, many will immediately label the evil man who condemned himself; however, Lady Macbeth is the one who is actually responsible for the actions and eventual downfall of Macbeth.
Macbeth Essay Can Lady Macbeth be blamed for Macbeth’s killings? Can Hitler be blamed for the Holocaust? William Shakespeare must have thought of the most heinous person in history to have constructed Lady Macbeth in his play, Macbeth. In raw form, Lady Macbeth is the instigator of murder, the epitome of evil, and, ultimately, the insinuator of her own demise. From the beginning, Lady Macbeth was in favor of Duncan’s murder.
Macbeth has fallen victim to the persuasion of others, which makes him most of all not responsible for his actions. Macbeths very own “person in crime” his wife, Lady Macbeth pursuaded her own husband to kill king Duncan so that
Who’s to blame for Macbeth’s downfall? In a tragic situation, who do we blame when everyone seems at fault? This seemingly depends on quite a few factors. Macbeth, the main character of Shakespeare’s tragic screenplay entitled Macbeth, slowly devolves throughout the play as he and his wife become more corrupted and climb the ranks in Scotland.
The downfall of Macbeth can be blamed on both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. The crimes committed by Macbeth are what ultimately caused his downfall. However, his decisions were strongly swayed by Lady Macbeth. The intent was equally to blame on the both of them. Lady Macbeth had a lust for power once she heard the prophecy from the witches.
Macbeth was clearly driven by something when making all of his choices. Rather that “something” was the witches, his wife, or simply his own ambition, there is a reason for his decisions. Which leads back to the question, “Who is responsible for the tragedy of Macbeth?” The first option is that the witches are the cause of Macbeth’s rise and fall. The witches provide the possibility that they are the reason for the tragedy.
Although humans are influenced by the close people around us, we are ultimately judged by our individual actions. In other words, it was Macbeth’s own actions that are responsible for his downfall. In the play Macbeth, Shakespeare exemplifies that Macbeth’s mental condition is to blame for his downfall. Shakespeare explores this theme and conflict through various examples such as Macbeth’s relationships with the three witches, Duncan, and Banquo.
In Shakespeare’s Macbeth, both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth contributed to the murder of King Duncan and the murders that follow. Macbeth is known for his bravery and courage as a soldier on the battlefield, and as a solider he is very familiar with killing people, which we later see throughout the play. This shows that Macbeth is solely responsible for the murders he commits throughout the play. Although, Macbeth may seem totally responsible for these murders, other characters actions in the play including Lady Macbeth, the witches, and himself led Macbeth to his downfall.