The United States federal government has one of the toughest jobs in the country. They are employed to rectify issues that seem to have no unblemished, concise answer. They have no way of making every one of the “320, 477, 300” American citizens satisfied, but that is exactly what their occupation entails (United States). The federal government officials are elected by those very citizens to accurately represent the multitude of voices in Congress and act accordingly. Is that even possible? Immigration is defined as the act of “com[ing] to a country of which one is not a native, usually for permanent residence” (Immigrate). This makes the process of immigration seem simple enough; however, the actual process is far from simple. The U.S. …show more content…
The U.S., however, experienced several, various bouts of isolationism and an intense desire to eradicate immigration. These led to drastic policies regarding immigration and what to do with the immigrants seeking asylum in the country of hope and prosperity.
This debate on immigration and amnesty have two distinct sides: those who believe that amnesty should be given to the undocumented immigrants already in the country and those who believe that no amnesty should be given. So, the question is: should the United States extend amnesty to the undocumented immigrants already in the U.S. or should the United States not extend amnesty and send them home?
Amnesty Should Be Given Many American citizens argue that amnesty should be extended to the undocumented immigrants already housed in the United States and their families. Sending the undocumented immigrants already housed in the United States is erroneous for several reasons. For example, the economic impact and the sociological/psychological impact that would be endowed on the United States if the undocumented immigrants were to be sent back to their home country. The economic impact that extending amnesty to the undocumented immigrants already in the United States would be relatively low and may help to stabilize the economy. The undocumented immigrants are already in the country and are, therefore contributing to the American economy system. They produce products along with buying products from various locations (i.e.
It would bring in 11 million new citizens who pay social security taxes and buy things”( Egan 1). Though attitudes towards immigrants are negative, immigration was not always bad, in fact it was once welcomed into America when it lacked a strong labor force. Most immigrants working in the U.S during this time learned that life as a worker here was better than their previous life. Both skilled and unskilled workers boosted the economy in strong times, but when the economy was on a fall, the unskilled laborers were hit hardest of all (Andryszewski 52).
The US federal government should allow amnesty for illegal immigrants in the country. The US federal government could provide a system for earning citizenship such as US military service. If illegal immigrants were given citizenship that would benefit the economy by raising wages, creating new jobs, and it would also generate more tax revenue.
The United States is a country that was built on immigration. The first settlers, Native Americans, represent less than 2% of the total population; the remaining 98% of the population are immigrants or decedents of immigrants. Today, the US still has the highest immigration rate in the world with 757,434 naturalizations in the 2012 fiscal year only (US Naturalizations 2012, Department of Homeland security). People try to immigrate to the United States for many reasons. Some people immigrate because they have been granted a refugee status or asylum and other people immigrate to fulfill their dreams. Immigration has an effect on the American society and economy. The US cannot survive without immigrants.
Since its founding, the United States has attracted immigrants from all over the world and consists of a variety of different cultures. Immigration has had an enormous impact on American society and economy and shaped the country remarkably.
If it were up to you, and you had the choice whether or not to give undocumented citizens a chance at citizenship, would you? Many people believe that they should not have a chance at citizenship because they came here illegally. Every person has their own opinion on this topic. This debate is one of many debates going on in between the candidates or even the politicians, but of course they all have their own views and reasons on it. Everyone should consider that they should because either we are hurting families or they can help improve our economy. In the next three paragraphs this argument will be influencing you to side with my claim, that undocumented citizens should get a pathway to citizenship.
Ever since the creation of the human race, human beings have been prone to moving place to place for new opportunities and beginnings. People who move from one country to another are called immigrants. As nations started to form, their were rules and laws set on who could and could not live in a specific country. Most of these laws included immigrants to go through a lengthy process to get approved to go into the country they desired. However, even after the lengthy process is completed, the country still has the right to deny their entrance. In fear of being rejected, many immigrants decided to illegally cross the borders of other countries causing many problems with the country's society, specially the United States of America. Historians saw a great example of this in the 1920s. The 1920s in America unfolded the greatest wave of immigration in American history; more than 25 million foreigners, also known as immigrants, arrived on American shores (Shmoop). Before the 1920s, immigration in the United States had never been systematically restricted by federal law, however that changed with the 1921 Emergency Quota Act and the 1924 Immigration Act. For the first time in American history, these acts imposed a limit on the number of immigrants allowed to enter the United States which eventually caused many to enter illegally. Today America is faced with some similar issues with immigration as they did in the 1920s, for example, the number of illegal immigrants in
I believe that immigration reform is necessary, but I think that if we allow amnesty for everyone that is already here, what is to prevent others to come in illegally and hope that the same thing will happen to them? Right now, America has several issues with its own citizens, such as homelessness and poverty. Mexico is not the only country that is struggling, and if we let in citizens regardless of whether or not they are financially stable, will they even do better here in the United States, or will they add to the homeless population? And if we help those that can’t afford to move, but want to, don’t we have a responsibility to move others from countries that are far worse off than Mexico? Immigration is an incredibly complex topic, and I am still unsure of what the best course of action would be for our
There are many pros to this topic, such as the fact that the government would earn more taxes. Most illegal aliens are paid under the table because of the law. If we provided the undocumented workers with amnesty, they could be paid legally and pay taxes. This would contribute to Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security, the NLCATP reported. Another positive would be that welfare dollars would be going toward American legal residents. So much money is going to illegal immigrants every year. What if we made them legal residents? The money would then be contributing to the welfare of Americans, no longer the foreigners. (“Pro and Cons of Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants.”)
Immigration has become a very relevant topic in the past few years and has sparked various arguments between Americans. No agreement has been reached regarding immigration reform, possibly because many people view it as an immediate amnesty rather than a possibility of legalization for hard-working immigrants. Despite of the negative meaning associated with it, an immigration reform would be beneficial to the U.S. in social aspects, such as having undivided families, and by stimulating economic growth.
Imagine being an illegal immigrant in your home with your children, working hard to give your children a better life, then suddenly ICE agents barge in and raid your home,rips you from your children who are now crying and scared, and physical force are used to force you out of your home. Unfortunately this is a reality for many. Being an undocumented immigrant is challenging because their fate is in the hands of the country’s government which is ruled by the people’s decisions. Illegal immigration has been a controversial topic which has been an issue for decades, however, the options that have been offered as a solution are amnesty or deportation. Deportation is usually the more unpleasant way which is dealing with the illegal immigrants by sending them back to their home country. Amnesty is being officially pardoned from an offense, usually political or federal. Amnesty is the best solution to the illegal immigration issue, a highly debated topic amongst politicians, for the reasons of the flourishing economy and the diversity of cultures with the social integration.
Imagine if someone broke into your house and your parents decided that the criminal would be forgiven and that he/she would be allowed to live with you. How would that make you feel? Now picture the government overlooking the fact that someone illegally entered our country and then giving them legal status in return. This is what happens when one is granted amnesty. In 1986, President Reagan signed the Immigration Reform and Control Act giving amnesty to about 3 million immigrants ("A Reagan Legacy: Amnesty for Illegal Immigrants"). This was only supposed to be a “one-time” deal, instead it has happened for seven occasions, and there will probably be more. The fact of the matter is that illegal immigrants should not receive
Every person is a human being, not an “alien”, and deserves every right, privilege, and freedom everyone has. I believe granting amnesty to immigrants can bring happiness in both the country and immigrants. For those who do not know what amnesty is, it is an official pardon for people who have been convicted of political offenses. My topic is about granting amnesty to immigrants in any country and to let them have every right a legal citizen has. I will be covering mostly on the immigrants who are currently living in the United States. Having illegal immigrants “Can help with the country 's economy”, “Bring a better life for immigrants”, and let them have more benefits. It also gives their “Children a better education and gives them better opportunities to succeed in school and have a better job”. Granting amnesty will help for both the country and people since these “Immigrants also pay for their taxes and work really hard for whatever job they have”. Also, It is nearly impossible to get rid of all the immigrants that live in the United States. “There are currently over 11 million immigrants in America”, just imagine the cost to get rid of them. Immigration is not such a bad thing. They are normal people who want to live in the American dream. They want the best for them and their family. They do not want to bring in trouble in America since America helps them live in a better life, that is all they want. America gives
Amnesty can help restore order in some cases when it comes to “Illegal Aliens”. Pardoning upheld citizens that are illegal aliens could help give a balance. A majority of the illegal immigrants want to take jobs that American citizens do not want. They will work for low income and several shifts to help support their families. A large portion of the settlers are trying to get away from drugs, sex slave trade, violence, and living in poverty. Immigrants can be on the run, changing their appearance, changing their
The article, “5 Reasons to Grant Amnesty to Illegal Immigrants” was written by the well educated journalist Ed Krayewski. Krayewski clearly establishes his opinion once the reader is familiar with the basics of immigration in America; the only feasible solution for solving immigration problems is to grant amnesty to illegal immigrants. The article presents a well organized explanation as to why the solution to immigration problems in America is granting amnesty. Krayewski provides five seemingly simple reasons to support his belief, but fails to prove wrong any contradictory information. Despite the controversial topic and lack of opposing material, Krayewski does maintain an excellent alternative view on the topic of illegal immigrants.
Not all agree that the “illegal aliens” should be able to get a chance to prove