preview

The book that I am reviewing is titled The Kurillion Knot: A History of Japanese-Russian Border

Better Essays

The book that I am reviewing is titled The Kurillion Knot: A History of Japanese-Russian Border Negotiations by Hiroshi Kimura. I will first make a general statement about what the book is about and how the research was conducted and then I will move on to discuss the arguments that are being made by the author. I will then move on and briefly outline the chapters of the book and then I will discuss the weaknesses of the book and then I will conclude my review.
General Statement: This book explores why there has been no peace treaty signed between Russia and Japan since the end of world war two. It also discusses the relations between Russian and Japan dating back to the 1600’s and discusses their complex relationship and also …show more content…

The author argued due to the bipolar US-Soviet relations, Japanese- Russian relations were “merely a subset of U.S-Soviet and U.S-Russian relations.” (Kimura)(pg.142) Also the author points out even though times have changed since the cold war and the fall of USSR, neither country gives each high priority towards trading and foreign policy. He even goes on to argue that both countries could totally ignore each other and get along just fine. (Kimura) ( pg 142)
 The four Kurille Islands:
In his other main point, the value of the four islands is central to his argument of strained relations between the two countries. The islands were both explored and claimed by both countries during interesting periods of history. When Japan explored the islands in the Tokugawa Period, they were in a period of extreme isolation. Russia explored the islands during the same period when they were in a period of expanding. (Kimura)(pg. 144)The islands are rich with oil and have some of the best fishing in the ocean. The author points out due to the expansive nature of the two countries, the need for resources only added fuel to the fire. (Kimura)(pg. 144) Japan viewed the small islands also known as the Kurille Islands

Get Access