preview

Traditional Security vs Human Security

Better Essays

TRADITIONAL SECURITY
VS HUMAN SECURITY
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
INSTRUCTOR: SURAT HORACHAIKUL
12/13/2012

TRADITIONAL SECURITY VS HUMAN SECURITY 2012
Table of Contents
1.

INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................................... 2

2.

TRADITIONAL SECURITY VS HUMAN SECURITY .................................................................................... 3
2.1.

TRADITIONAL SECURITY ................................................................................................................ 3

2.2.

HUMAN SECURITY …show more content…

There are critics of the concept of human security which claim that if all the components of well-being are included, the term will become essentially meaningless, as it permits the inclusion of practically everything that affects any larger groups of individuals adversely.1

2.3.RELATION OF TRADITIONAL SECURITY AND HUMAN SECURITY
Human security is a very broad concept of security and has been developed in order to challenge traditional security studies, after people realized that nowadays poverty, diseases, and natural disaster are a much bigger threat to the security of people than war. However even though human security has emerged as a challenge of ideas, human and traditional/national security are not mutually exclusive concepts. Many people have argued that it is not possible to attain human security without traditional security and the other way around.

1

Security Studies Today - Terry Terriff, Stuart Croft, Lucy James, Patrick Morgan - 1999

RANGSIT UNIVERSITY

3

TRADITIONAL SECURITY VS HUMAN SECURITY 2012
When you analyze the relation of traditional security and human security, you can take 4 different factors in order to explain the main differences.
Referent
While human security is people-centered and its focus shifts to protect individuals, traditional security policies are created to promote demands from the state. Furthermore all other interests are subordinated to those of the state; traditional security

Get Access