preview

True Happiness: An Excerpt From Plato's The Republic

Decent Essays

True Happiness The definition of happiness varies from individual to individual. Some argue that happiness is an emotion, others argue that it is a state of being. The various perceptions that people hold of happiness illuminates its abstract and ambiguous nature. This variability, in regards to happiness, is displayed throughout history from the Hellenistic schools of philosophy and the Ancient philosophers to more modern day theologians such as C.S Lewis and Alister McGrath. Despite the various views of happiness, there are many similarities between them. Chapter 3 of Alister McGrath’s Theology The Basics and excerpts from Plato’s The Republic both depict distinct but similar views of happiness, however the perception of happiness implied …show more content…

Plato’s cave analogy described in his work portrays the release of a man from a dark cave to the real world. The man is dragged out by someone else to the light, but once he finally leaves the cave (material world) to the outside world (world of ideas), he recalls his fellow prisoners in the cave and “consider[s] himself happy for the change” (insert citation). The man has to be dragged out of the cave because he is content with where he is. He needs someone else to help him get to the place where he can achieve happiness. This dependent quality of Plato’s definition of happiness is also depicted by his description of the man’s thoughts. The man only comes to the realization that he is indeed happy when he compares himself to the other prisoners in the cave. Through his recollection of those who are still in the cave, the man is able to remind himself of his old state of being and come to the full realization of his current state of happiness. The man’s contentment within the cave further implies that the concept of happiness in the material world is not true happiness even though it appears and feels like true happiness. The notion of happiness in the material world includes material things such as wealth and physical comforts. Instead of conforming to this notion, Plato implies that happiness, is only achieved through a release from the material world and material things to the world of ideas containing the perfect forms. The man in the cave in Plato’s analogy is released from his prior condition. This allows the man to reach the real world, where is able to become happy. Through this, Plato further implies that freedom must be attained before happiness can be attained. The man’s happiness is not due to feelings of euphoria or extreme joy but to the particular condition that he is

Get Access