preview

United States Prison System Analysis

Better Essays

The United States prison system is an institution which has undergone dramatic changes in its history, from being a short detention center between a criminal and their true punishment, to what was thought to be a place for wayward souls to be rehabilitated through isolation, hard work, and religious repentance so they could reenter society without committing crimes again, to a place of overcrowded conditions, corruption, and prisoner abuse that existed solely for the sake of punishment. Since the prison system reached that point, there have been numerous attempted reforms of the system, and while they all ultimately failed at their goal of completely overhauling the system, they have all at least partly contributed to what we see in the United …show more content…

During the eighteenth century, the Enlightenment was in full steam, and over its course it became one of the instances of a change in the American way of thinking which led to new ideas of what rehabilitation was, and what forms it could take. During this period, people began to doubt whether the punishments that had been in effect were actually working as a deterrence. The reasoning was, “When the penalty for theft, for example, is the same as the penalty for murder, rational thieves will realize that it makes no sense to leave witnesses to their crimes.” This led to a reduction in the number of crimes punishable by death, but the punishments of the time did not possess the variety needed to be able to correctly match the punishment to the crime. So came the idea of employing the prison, which had always been used for debtors or as a stop between the offender and their actual punishment, as the punishment itself with varying sentences depending on the crime. As a result of the Enlightenment thinking of the time, the developers of the first modern prison systems believed that these prisons would rehabilitate prisoners through isolation, hard work, and religious repentance, thus they came to be known as penitentiaries. This new form of prison was only practiced in a few areas in the …show more content…

The prison system in place was never designed to contain that many prisoners so the system became highly inefficient. With this inefficiency came many activities such as corruption and prisoner abuse that were able to be hidden and continued on without repercussion. Solitary confinement was used as a tool of punishment and convenience, the guards putting prisoners in solitary for the slightest offenses, to teach the rest of the prisoners a lesson, and even simply because the guard did not like a certain prisoner. This was soon followed by attempts at reforming the system with policies of treating prisoners humanely and providing them with tools to help better themselves, such as skill training, education, and therapy, more modern forms of rehabilitative measures. Though this attempt soon failed due to the rampant overpopulation, which the reformers’ programs of rehabilitation simply could not keep up with. This pattern of overpopulation and prisoner abuse followed by failed attempts at prison reform continue to this day, though as evidenced by prison rehabilitative measures today, skill and job training, education, and therapy and counseling, the reforms

Get Access