preview

Veganism And Vegetarianism, By Tzachi Zamir

Decent Essays

In Veganism written by Tzachi Zamir digests the complexity of Veganism and Vegetarianism. He expresses the different perspectives through five arguments that argue for either Veganism or Vegetarianism. The first part of his argument simply paints the picture for the reader to understand the relationship between animals and humans and the dynamic of the relationship. The second and third arguments are similar because they dissects the ideal of humans choosing the fate of an animal. Zamir research is able to argue the perspective of Vegans and Vegetarians. Zamir’s fourth part of the argument uses evidence that a large portion of vegans are inconsistent with their “Veganism”, most of them are only Vegan when it’s convenient or for social …show more content…

The second and third argument are similar because they pertain to the fate of the animal. Zamir starts his second argument by stating that “pet shows that human-animal relations need not be exploitive.” Following up on his initial argument, he is arguing against the Vegan perspective stating that human don’t know how to treat animals. He writes that “cows, sheep, and chickens are not pets”, so people utilize them different. It is very rare for a young child to say that they want a pet cow, children ask for cats or dogs as pets. Since the function of farm animals (or animals that we consume are different) is leads to even more questions such as “Should this life be lived?” For this argument in particular, Zamir states that the Vegans are correct because humans should not be able to choose which life is worth living. Zamir’s third argument is the “benefiting” or “harming” the life is “determined by three dimensions: the quantitative, the qualitative, and the teleological.” He writes that both vegans and vegetarians can both agree that the principle of choosing the fate for the animal is cruel. Most farmers chose to kill the animals for their own personal and monetary gain. The moral vegetarian, however, can still benefit from “Euthanasia” in this instance if the animal gets sick or is about to die.

Zamir’s fourth argument states that being Vegan requires being Vegan all the times, not when it is just convenient for the person. Being a

Get Access