preview

Western Civilization Religion

Decent Essays

Sam Huntington's claims that Western ideas do not resonate with civilizations from the East is incorrect. Huntington only acknowledges that Western ideas were developed by the West when ideas such as the separation of the church and state weren’t practiced by Western civilizations all throughout Western history, while also ignoring the history of Eastern civilizations having similar ideas, namely liberty. The separation of the church and state is so-called a Western idea when most Western civilizations at time still closely linked religion and government together. An example is Castile, a kingdom in Iberia(Haberman 7). Choosing one of Castile's major city at the time, for instance Seville, it can be observed how the church played a big role in the city around the 15th century. The Roman Catholic Church was easily the commanding institute in Seville owning “about 10 …show more content…

Taxes on people who are not affiliated with the nation’s official religion was to usually encourage conversion to the official religion for lesser taxes so Akbar’s decision to stop the extra fees really shows his acceptance to different religions. Akbar even encouraged theological talks in one of his major cities, Fatehpur Sikri, with people ranging from Muslims, Hindus, Zoroastrians, etc(Haberman, 13). Given this, the liberty of practicing your own religion and own customs were not so alien concepts in Eastern civilizations like the Ottoman Empire and the Mughal Empire. To conclude, Huntington’s is wrong to assume that Western ideas do not resonate with Eastern civilizations. The West did not always follow Western ideas like the separation of church and state throughout its history with the city of Seville showcasing how much property the Church held. Religious liberty and keeping your customs was occurring in the Eastern nation as

Get Access