preview

What Are The Problems In Susan Calvin's A Brief History Of Robots

Decent Essays

This is a book of stories told by Susan Calvin of the history of robots and how they evolved. The robots were programmed with three unbreakable laws. First, a robot may not injure a human or purposely allow a human to come to harm. Second, a robot must obey the orders given to it by humans except when they would conflict with the first law. Finally, a robot must protect its own existence as long as it does not conflict with the first or second law. Even though the laws are in place problems still occurred when the laws conflict with each other or are taken to the extreme and put humans at risk. Because of this, humans should have been against robots and artificial intelligence from the beginning. An example of these problems was on …show more content…

Susan was there to learn more as her job as a robopsychologist. When she went to talk to the robot, Herbie, she was told that Milton Ashe, here partner who she also loved, loved her back. Of course she believed him because he could supposedly read minds. Later that day Milton told Susan that he was getting married and she was devastated. She figured out that she was not the only one that had been lied to, the other workers had been told only what they wanted to hear too. She went to Herbie who’s reasoning was he didn’t want to break the first law and hurt them so he told them what they wanted to hear. Susan continuously repeated to Herbie, “You can’t tell them, because that would hurt and you mustn’t hurt. But if you don’t tell them, you hurt, so you must tell them.” Finally, Herbie screamed and stopped moving which was the equivalent of insanity. Herbie didn’t want to hurt them emotionally as well as physically but by trying to not hurt Susan he did just that. The first law of robotics conflicted with itself making lying seemingly okay up until the truth came out. After this, Susan was never the

Get Access