preview

Who Is Livy On Promoting A Common Good

Decent Essays

2) As Machiavelli says, “Such dominions thus acquired are either accustomed to live under a prince, or to live in freedom,” (1). A prince ruling over a country doesn't allow them to be free and thus doesn't promote a common good. The Prince opposes Discourses on Livy on promoting a common good because the prince ruins the countries he steals. The Prince is in direct relation to Discourses of Livy's theory by contradiction. In The Prince, Machiavelli first says, “for men change their rulers willingly, hoping to better themselves,... They are deceived, because they afterwards find by experience they have gone from bad to worse,” (4). This proves that the new Prince that rules over them is not for the interests of them at all, since they went to from bad to worse. Furthermore, proving the …show more content…

The Prince sends in colonies to protect himself. He uses fear to kept half the population quiet, and makes the other half poor by kicking them out of their homes. This is not promoting a common good. It's promoting a singular good for the Prince. Later it discusses how the Prince should permit the country to remain free, but the free country will in the end rebel against him, this being the only part in the story that promotes a common good at all, but knowing the country will rebel on him, the prince likely will not let them be free (20-21). Even farther on The Prince says, “...neither can he rely on his

Get Access