preview

Why Does Socrates Think That ' Right Conduct ' Can Not Be Defined As `` Telling The Truth And

Satisfactory Essays
Interview With Plato:
Question: In your writing, why does Socrates think that ‘right conduct’ cannot be defined as "telling the truth and restoring anything we have been trusted with"?
Answer:
Question: What important questions does the dialogue the republic attempt to answer? Answer:
Question: Could you please explain how each of the three cardinal virtue other than justice are exemplified in the individual soul?
Answer: Before Socrates discusses these virtues, he explains that the virtues cannot exist unless the city is already "just." Justice has been taken care of. These virtues begin with wisdom which is shown by those "guardians" who oversee the city and who make sure the city runs as it has been designed to run. The second
…show more content…
Answer: Socrates believed that women should be given the same education, music and gymnasium, as their male counterparts. However, he says that though the two sexes share identical pursuits, comparatively, males quantitatively surpass females in these pursuits nearly always.
Question: How can Socrates find true social justice in his ideal city? What does he expect from true justice, and why does he think his city can uphold it?
Answer: One part of the political system focuses on specialization, the idea that each person would perform that "job" for which he is most suited. He would then stick to that job and that would satisfy him and thus keep structural order. Once this specialization occurs, there will be classes in the city and each class will do what it needs to do to make the city run smoothly: warriors, rulers, and producers will keep the city functioning smoothly. Rulers will make the rules, warriors will carry out the rulers ' commands, and producers will only figure out how their production helps the city. Socrates believes that if the city is set up this way, it will be a just city.
Question: What problem does Socrates point out with Polemarchus’ claim that justice is doing good to your friends and harm to your enemies?
Answer: Socrates points out that our judgment concerning friends and enemies isn 't foolproof, and that taking this stance leads us to harm the good and help the bad. Unless we choose our friends according to their virtues (assuming
Get Access