preview

Witness, By Australian Peter Weir

Decent Essays

Introduction:
Witness is a film which explores the differences between the modern American and traditional Amish communities. Directed by Australian Peter Weir, the film is set in 1985, in Pennsylvania, America. Rachel Lapp and her young son, Samuel, leave the Amish community to travel to Baltimore to visit Rachel’s sister. Whilst waiting at the train station Samuel enters the bathroom where he witnesses a murder of a police officer. This involves the appropriately named honest detective John Book, who investigate the murder and does things by the book. Witness brings together two different worlds and explores the effects. Witness also discusses organizational culture in its revelations of the Philadelphia police force’s entrenched corruption. …show more content…

Cultural differences between two very different societies are explored throughout the film. One of the very first scenes shows the contrast in technology. Rachel and Samuel board a train, a modern machine, whilst Daniel rides a horse drawn carriage. Although Daniel looks very manly, his carriage quickly falls behind of the speeding train. This represents how the Amish are slower than the modern world. Not only in transport; are the Amish slower also in the ways of how they communicate. This is evident when Book asks to use a phone but there was none in the Lapps house hold. Instead a community phone is used. However, Weir contrasts and compares the Amish favorably particularly their values and morality. Rachel is compared to John’s sister Elaine, when she stays the night. Both are single mothers, but John believes that Elaine is immoral bringing men into the house whilst her children are asleep. Rachel on the other hand kindly tucks her son into bed and is close with her family. When a group of young American teenagers harass Daniel, an Amish, Book jumps hastily to defend Daniel, however, Eli warns him “that it is not [the Amish] way” Book replies, “But it’s my way!”. Being a trained officer he attacks the young man, with more force than what was necessary. This incident shows Book’s violent culture as opposed to the peace loving Amish culture. Two different, diverse cultures are studied and the …show more content…

In the Amish community, Samuel found Book’s gun in the shelf, Eli warns Samuel of the dangers of the gun and how it is unwelcomed in Samuel’s community. This powerful scene shows the loss of innocence in Samuel and the peaceful beliefs of the Amish. This is compared to the scenario of the story where the corruption and base of this thriller is because of drug deals within high officials of the Philadelphia police station. The corruption from high officials is passed down to lower levels police officers. The greed for money from these drug deals causes the imminent death of a police officer who is supposedly is a part of the team. This represents how far the corruption can lead, all because of greed for money.
Conclusion:
Witness is a deep film which explores many aspects of the modern world and compares it to the prehistoric life-style of the Amish. It highlights the important of socialism and represents how two different cultures can

Get Access