preview

Women's History Scholarship Summary

Decent Essays

This reading list examines recent United States Women’s History scholarship. The anthologies reveal several themes and agendas. Scholars seek to connect women’s history to larger American narratives. Questions regarding race, class, labor, power, gender roles, and female influence on public policy/politics dominate the discussions. A leading concern is incorporating the histories of women of color and diverse ethnic backgrounds, and working class women, into the prevailing standard narrative of women’s history. Scholars grapple with the racial aspect of the suffrage narrative, and particularly racism as inherent to suffragist leadership, as a political strategy, or both. When considering the “waves” metaphor and standard periodization, many …show more content…

How do scholars become inclusive of the myriad of American class, race, and ethnic narratives and identify common themes to create an over arching interconnected narrative? Should scholars employ a comparative approach rather than attempting interconnectivity as they make forays into revising the narrative? The push for revision and inclusion based on differences, and for inclusion of women’s history in the overarching American narrative is important to develop a more complex understanding of American history. There is much work needed examining diverse histories of American women before scholars can truly develop and synthesize an expansive standard narrative. This must begin in early United States history, and include early influences and perhaps individual and community studies, rather than focus on the more recent past. Scholars must synthesize how American women of different class, race, ethnicity, region, acted or reacted at the exact same time in history. Despite the exclusive nature of the standard suffrage narrative, or the question of its centrality in American women’s history, the standard works as a progressive guide. It explains how franchise happened, and draws together many elements of women’s history. The suffrage narrative interconnects with many of the important “female” topics and

Get Access