6 6a 6b 6c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 6 x 20 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation Ag (mm2) 3787 Weight 5323 4568 3974 width mm flange bf thickness kg/m d (depth) 30 W6 x 20 157.48 152.91 9.27 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narat ve form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 28 42 204.72 165.99 11.81 W8 x 24 36 164.97 201.42 210.31 W8 x 21 31 133.86 tf 10.16 Web 10.16 thickness tw 6.60 Elastic Properties mm 4 mm 3 Ix x 106 7.24 6.22 6.35 17 41 34 31 Sxx 103 220 398 342 298 mm rx 67.56 87.63 86.87 88.65 mm 4 lyx 106 6 9 8 4 mm 3 Syx 106 72 109 92 61 mm ry 38.10244 41.15 40.89 32 Plastic properties mm 3 Zx x 103 244 446 380 334 mm 3 Zyx 103 110 166 140 93 h=d-2k h 120.65 155.58 155.58 168.28

Steel Design (Activate Learning with these NEW titles from Engineering!)
6th Edition
ISBN:9781337094740
Author:Segui, William T.
Publisher:Segui, William T.
Chapter5: Beams
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 5.13.1P
icon
Related questions
Question
6
6a
6b
6c
Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical
section is W 6 x 20 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you
are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why?
Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa
Designation
W8 x 24
W8 x 21
Weight
Ag (mm2)
3787
36
31
width
mm
kg/m d (depth)
30
157.48
152.91
9.27
W6 x 20
expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narative form to support your cho'ce)
W8 x 28
42
204.72
165.99
11.81
5323
4568
201.42
164.97
10.16
3974
210.31
133.86
flange
bf
thickness
tf
Web
10.16
thickness
tw
6.60
Elastic Properties
mm 4
Ix x 106
7.24
6.22
6.35
17
41
34
31
mm 3
Sxx 103
220
398
342
298
mm
rx
67.56
87.63
86.87
88.65
mm 4
lyx 106
6
9
8
4
mm 3
Syx 106
72
109
92
61
mm
ry
38.10244
41.15
40.89
32
Plastic properties.
mm 3
Zx x 103
244
446
380
334
mm 3
Zyx 103
110
166
140
93
h=d-2k
h
120.65
155.58
155.58
168.28
Transcribed Image Text:6 6a 6b 6c Alaterally supported beam was designed for flexure. The beam is safe for shear & deflection. The most economical section is W 6 x 20 however the said section is not readily available at the time of the construction. If you are the engineer in charge of the construction what alternative section will be the best replacement? Why? Use: Fy=248 MPa: E=200,000 MPa Designation W8 x 24 W8 x 21 Weight Ag (mm2) 3787 36 31 width mm kg/m d (depth) 30 157.48 152.91 9.27 W6 x 20 expla'n briefly your cho'ce. (transform your comparative analys's 'nto a narative form to support your cho'ce) W8 x 28 42 204.72 165.99 11.81 5323 4568 201.42 164.97 10.16 3974 210.31 133.86 flange bf thickness tf Web 10.16 thickness tw 6.60 Elastic Properties mm 4 Ix x 106 7.24 6.22 6.35 17 41 34 31 mm 3 Sxx 103 220 398 342 298 mm rx 67.56 87.63 86.87 88.65 mm 4 lyx 106 6 9 8 4 mm 3 Syx 106 72 109 92 61 mm ry 38.10244 41.15 40.89 32 Plastic properties. mm 3 Zx x 103 244 446 380 334 mm 3 Zyx 103 110 166 140 93 h=d-2k h 120.65 155.58 155.58 168.28
Expert Solution
steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Bars
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, civil-engineering and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Steel Design (Activate Learning with these NEW ti…
Steel Design (Activate Learning with these NEW ti…
Civil Engineering
ISBN:
9781337094740
Author:
Segui, William T.
Publisher:
Cengage Learning