(1) What is functionalism? What are the pros and cons of functionalism? Explain how you would challenge functionalism.
The theory of functionalism first entered the world of philosophy and, more specifically, the world of materialism, at a time when the identity theory and behaviourism were beginning to be questioned. Advocates of functionalism use the theory to explain mental causation, a concept that behaviourism did not address, and multiple realisation, a concept that the identity theory was unable to explain. Mental causation is the notion that the mental state of a being is causing the individual’s behaviour. Multiple realisation is the idea that any person and any species can experience the same sensation, despite differences in physical structure and wiring. Functionalists argue that the
…show more content…
One possible argument against Shoemaker’s metaphysical approach involves a slight alteration of the intrasubjective inverted spectrum scenario. Suppose that, an individual wakes one one day with a changed qualia and, using the previously mentioned example, see the green of grass in the same way as they used to see the red of a rose (among other changes). However, unlike the original intrasubjective version, they do not realise that this change has occurred and do not remember that they used to see the green of grass differently, nor do they sense any difference in feeling when looking at grass. In this scenario, there is no possibility of behavioural differences, as the person does not even know that they are experiencing qualitative differences. If this this true, then for the inverted spectrum to occur, in this scenario, there would be qualitative differences without behavioural differences – meaning that functionalism would have to be false for the inverted spectrum to be true. This scenario appears to be possible, so functionalism must be
Functionalism was developed as a combination of the Behaviorist theory and the Identity theory. Behaviorism believes being in a mental state is the same as a physical state, which is a noticeable behavioral characteristic. For instance, if one claims they are unhappy, there physical state could include a frowning display or inappropriate posture. On the other hand, the Identity Theory suggests when one
According to Griffiths & et. al (2015), functionalism is a structure with interrelated parts designed to meet the biological and social needs of the individuals in that
In this essay, I am going to write a response to the objection raised by the functionalists towards identity theory. Identity theory is a form of physicalism; it states that a particular mental state is identical to a particular physical state of body and brain, for instance mental sensation such as pain is simply just the firing of C-fibres (Smart, 1959). This is a reductionist view as it reduces our psychological state to a materialistic and physical form. A prominent objection against identity theory is Functionalism, in which the main advocate Hilary Putnam stated that identity theory is too narrow as it ignores multiple realisability. In the next paragraph, I will write a little more about functionalism, and in the end, I will ultimately conclude that functionalism is a better theory than identity theory.
In this essay I am going to compare and contrast Functionalism and Marxism. They are both sociological perspectives which have theories about society and the people that live within it. They attempt to explain how society influences people, and similarly how people influence society. However, the two perspectives are clearly different.
1.Compare and contrast the conflict and the functionalist perspective relative to the political system in the United States. Select one current issue such as healthcare, immigration, or one of your choosing and discuss the issue from both perspectives.
In Harman’s paper, “The Intrinsic Quality of Experience,” he defends the concept of functionalism, which is the theory that mental states are identified by what they do as opposed to what they are made of. Harman defends functionalism by stating the three familiar arguments against functionalism and then refutes those arguments. Out of the three oppositions to functionalism, the inverted spectrum argument is the best.
Functionalism was developed as a response against structuralism and I think that at the time it was considered that psychological functions could be best understood in relation to their function rather than their structure. I think that at that particular time of period the study of structuralism was based on what happens when an individual does something, and functionalism studied how and why. Functionalism developed according to evolutionary theory when structuralism focused on
The easiest and most general way to understand the functionalist view is through the example of a Turing machine. This is an abstract model of a machine, proposed by Alan Turing, which has a tape that can move infinitely in either direction, a scanner/sensor and a small printer attachment. On the tape there is a random sequence of symbols or lack thereof. The symbol at a specific point along the tape, chosen from a finite alphabet of
Functionalism is a theory of the mind in contemporary philosophy, developed largely as an alternative to both the identity theory of mind and behaviorism. Its main idea is that mental states are constituted solely by their functional role. The conflict perspective views the social world as difficult unfair and unreasonable. This perspective is typically more pessimistic. Symbolic interactionism is a theory that develops from practical considerations and that alludes to people's particular utilization of dialect to make images, normal implications, for deduction and correspondence with others.
The second version of functionalism is causal-theoretical functionalism. Causal-theoretical functionalism classifies mental states in terms of their psychological theory. There are two versions of psychological theory:
What is functionalist? Functionalist is a type of phenomenon that creates a social order. This also gives people some type of perpus in life and makes them want to contribute to society. Over time this type of behavior become a pattern. Emile Durkheim was the one who came with this theory.
The functionalism theory is also known as structural functionalism and lays claim on the fact that the society is composed of interdependent portions each of which adds to the functioning of the whole society. Functionalists break
Functionalism developed out of the positivist observation that 'all positive speculations owe their first origin to the occupations of practical life' (Comte, 1865, pg 11) and the boundaries of scientific knowledge can not go further than empirically observable truths and views societies as holistic systems where 'the whole is greater than the sum of its parts' (Taylor et el, 1997, pg 662). Functionalist analysis draws on three assumptions essentially seeking to transform society into a theoretical system of reality. The first assumption is that there are zero independent parts operating within
In the philosophy of mind, there are many theories that try to resolve the mind-body problem. That is, how does the mental or consciousness interact with our physical body? Do they interact at all? Are they two separate entities or one in the same? Many theories try to answer these types of questions, but the one I will be focusing on is role functionalism. When mentioning functionalism throughout, I will be referring to role functionalism. Functionalism is a theory that says mental states can be defined by their function. So, we can identify mental states with their functional states. We can come to know the function of a mental state through examining its inputs, outputs, and relation to other mental states. I will show how this theory is correct by comparing it to the identity theory. I will begin by clarifying a few important terms in relation to functionalism, lay out the theory, and then present an objection. Lastly, I will present a possible functionalist reply to the objection and conclude.
Functionalist theory is one of the major theoretical perspectives in sociology. It can be argued that the functionalist theory has made a significant contribution to the study of society. It originates from the work of Emile Durkheim who suggests that social order is possible and society remains stable due to the functioning of several institutions. Everything has a specific function in society and society will always function in harmony. The main institutions studied by functionalism are the family, the education system, religion and crime and deviance.