FBE 432 - Class Objectives and Problem Assignments
J. K. Dietrich
Week 11 – November 4 and 6, 2002
Goals and Objectives
(1) Calculate the value of and interpret the sustainable growth rate for a firm
(2) Trace the implications on financial policy of growth rates higher and lower than the sustainable growth rate for a firm
(3) Discuss the importance of financial flexibility and critically assess the trade-offs from use of various financial options in implementing a firm’s strategy
Suggested Review Reading for next Class
RWJ, Chapter 18
Questions for Next Case (November 18, 2002*, Avon Products) * Note change in date in response to student preferences
(1) Evaluate Avon’s investment and financing decisions in the late 1980’s. Why
…show more content…
(2) Is this the right time for Huaneng Power International (HPI) to raise capital overseas? What are the benefits to HPI of listing on a U.S. exchange? Are there other financing alternatives the HPI should have considered?
(4) Was the chosen issue price for HPI reasonable? What is a reasonable value for 25% of HPI?
(5) Will foreign investors be interested in buying stock in this company? Should HPI proceed with this issue?
(6) Given the economic, political, and social environment in the PRC, would you recommend that U.S. institutional investors buy stock in HPI?
Note: HPI will issue 1,250,000,000 new B shares to bring the total number of shares outstanding to 5 billion. Each ADR represents 40 B class shares. To get cash flows, you need to estimate the firm’s capital expenditures. This can be done using the data in Exhibit 10, noting that capital expenditures in year t equals net assets in year t+1 minus net assets in year t + depreciation in year t. Regarding the data in Exhibit 14, keep in mind that the projected EPS of $1.45 is for an ADR, not an ordinary share.
Important Vocabulary List from Class
SUSTAINABLE GROWTH
OPTIMAL GROWTH
ACTUAL GROWTH
DEBT POLICY, DIVIDEND POLICY
FINANCIAL FLEXIBILITY
Suggested Wall Street Journal (WSJ) or other Articles
October 28,
c. SDI’s officers have been under pressure from the board of directors to do something to improve the price of the common stock. Management is also concerned about the stock price personally because bonuses are based on the performance of SDI’s stock price relative to other firms in its industry. So, they would like a detailed explanation of how the market price is determined—what do investors look for, and what can management do to provide what investors want? Bob Wilkes also wants you to explain how stock valuation information be used to help estimate the company’s cost of equity. Tony Biddle provided some information that can be used in the stock valuation process. First, as background on what investors think about the company, here are some representative quotations taken from analysts’ reports issued during the past few years.
Three interrogations were thus to answer. Should the company provide investors with classic bonds or give them the opportunity to convert them into equity? Should they structure the offer with a fixed or a floating coupon rate? And last but not least, where should they locate the operation?
3. They charged a higher than fair price in the Secondary Market. They sold the issue slowly in order to maintain the premium.
The sustainable growth rate is the rate at which a firm can grow while keeping its profitability and financial policies unchanged. The model allows an analyst to isolate drivers that have led to changes in historical growth in order to isolate causes of change. It is represented in four steps.
Question 5: Evaluate the Put-Warrant/Convertible Bond proposal. Does it solve Intel’s capital structure dilemma? What arguments might be made in favor of it?
a. What risk-free rate and risk premium did you use to calculate the cost of equity?
1. Assess Interco’s financial performance. Why is the company a target of a hostile takeover attempt?
Using the data provided in Exhibit 1, we can get free cash flow of year 2007-2011 would be $21.24 million, $26.73 million, $22.10 million, $25.47 million, and $29.54 million respectively. The computation is showed in Exhibit 1($ in thousands).
• Pe = D1/(re – g) = 700 / (0.11 – 0.05) = $11,667 • price per share = $11,667 / 1,000 = $11.67 3. Same facts as (2) above, except the 5% income growth rate (and beginning of year common equity to support it) are only expected for years 2 and 3. Then growth is expected to be zero and all income is expected to be distributed to shareholders for all future years. a. Compute D1, D2, D3, and Dt for all future years. • Keeping in mind that income is $1,100 in year 1, increases by 5% in years 2 and 3, and then remains constant for all future years; and keeping in mind that beginning of year 1 common equity is $8,000, increases by 5% at the beginning of year 2 and at the beginning of year 3, but does not increase at the beginning of year 4 and remains constant from that point forward, you should be able to compute: D1 = $700, D2 = $735, and Dt = 1,212.75 for D3 and all future years. b. Use the dividend discount (i.e., free cash flow to equity investors) valuation model to estimate the company’s current stock price. Pe = 700/(1+ 0.11) + 735/(1+ 0.11)2 + [1,212.75/0.11]/(1+ 0.11)2 = $10,175.31 and the price per share of common stock = $10,175.31 / 1,000 = $10.18. 4. Same facts as (3) above, except the growth rates are 5% for years 2 and 3 and then 3% perpetually for all future years. a. Compute D1, D2, D3 and the growth in D for all future years. • Keeping in mind that income is $1,100 in year 1, increases by 5% in years 2
(Note: retained earnings information is irrelevant here) Part b. Total market value = debt + pref. equity + Common equity = 1,147,200 + 1,250,000 + 2,500,000 = $4,897,200
2. Do you favor the proposed acquisition of UCP? What are the primary sources of value in such a transaction? Is the proposed price reasonable?
4. Are a member of HP’s Investment Committee, would you agree with the proposals to:
Strategy formulation has been acknowledged as one of the most crucial factors of ensuring the long-term growth of the business. However, the manner in which strategy is formulated, and most importantly, the nature of the strategy chosen for the company determines its future position in the marketplace (Grant, 2005).
5. As a shareholder, how would you approve the VEP? Would you elect cash or stock?
Summit Partners proposes to FleetCor Technologies (later preferred as “FleetCor” or the “Company”) an investment into FleetCor for the total amount of $44.9 million in return for a post transaction ownership of 54.2% in the “Company” and coming down to 46% ownership in the company after newly created stock options for management equivalent to 15% ownership in the company has been completely executed and fully diluted. This investment is in the form of convertible preferred stock with an 8% accrued interest, compounding annually. As the transaction come through, Summit’s prefer stock will be treated equal-footing in