preview

A Comparison Of The Glass Menagerie

Decent Essays

While reading Tennessee Williams play, “The Glass Menagerie”, readers are drawn into the drama and disaster that is the Wingfield family. There were several different film and television versions of this play done thru the years from 1950 to 1987. After watching several different adaptations, Paul Newman’s film adaptation in 1987 is extremely faithful to the written version. Focusing on plot, setting, and character development the audience is introduced to a family with an austere future structured around a series of abandonments, difficulty accepting reality and the impossibility of true escape. Both versions begin with a narrator looking back at the past and setting the stage for what memories will follow. The story is told in hindsight by Tom. It begins with Laura and Amanda waiting at the dining table for Tom to join them, so they can say grace and begin the meal, showing the audience, the family is very close and depend on each other. Throughout, readers also see constant conflict between the mother and children, but never conflict between the siblings. For instance, when Williams writes after an argument between Tom and Amanda; “AMANDA: “I won’t speak to you until you apologize!” (25) then the next morning Amanda sending Laura out, so she can talk to Tom privately to discuss Laura’s future. Trying to provide security to Laura and Amanda (at Amanda’s request), Tom invites and friend, Jim, home from work to meet his sister in the hopes that he will assume the

Get Access