preview

A Comparison of a Hobbsian World and the World of Candide

Best Essays

The Disparity between a Hobbsian World and the World of Candide

In an anarchistic Hobbsian world, man leads a purely selfish

existence, perpetually waging war against his fellow men. In this

world Nature subsists as a playing field for evolution: only the

strong and cunning survives, and even survival results in life that is

"nasty, brutish, and short" (Hobbes). However, with restraints (that

is, government), a Hobbsian world can blossom into society. According

to Hobbes, those who wish to subside from natural anarchy must

implicitly surrender some personal freedom in exchange for societal

order.

Hobbes' philosophies influenced many of his contemporaries and

subsequent …show more content…

Actually, there are only two settings in all of Candide where

adversity is somewhat alleviated. These settings are Eldorado and the

garden, and they both present critiques and corroborations of Hobbsian

philosophy.

When Candide and Cacambo first reach Eldorado, they are overwhelmed by

the Eldoradian's independence from material greed. Candide observes a

group of children playing ninepins with gold nuggets and then leaving

behind the gold when they are finished. Candide takes this gold and

attempts to use it to pay for a meal, only to become laughed at by an

innkeeper, who pronounces:

"Gentlemen, it is obvious that you are strangers here, and we are not

used to foreigners. So please excuse our laughter at your offering to

pay us with stones off the road. I dare say you haven't any of our

money, but you don't need any to dine here. All ins run for the

convenience of tradespeople are paid for by the Government. You have

fared badly here because this is a poor village, but everywhere else

you will be received as you deserve to be" (77).

Candide considers the innkeeper's words and remarks rhetorically:

"What country can this be?...everything is so different from what we

are used to. It is probably the country where all goes well" (77).

Eldoradian society partially confirms Candide's response. There are

no jails in Eldorado, no hunger or

Get Access